Novella Review: The Dispatcher by John Scalzi

I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.

The Dispatcher by John Scalzi

Mogsy’s Rating: 4 of 5 stars

Genre: Science Fiction

Series: Stand Alone

Publisher: Subterranean Press (May 31, 2017)

Length: 136 pages

Author Information: Website | Twitter

Imagine a world where it is nearly impossible to kill anyone. In The Dispatcher, John Scalzi’s sci-fi novella which takes place in the not-so-far future, this is exactly the state of affairs. One day, people simply woke up to this new game changer. If you committed suicide, you stayed dead. If you died in an accident, you stayed dead. If you passed away due to illness, you stayed dead. But for some bizarre reason, if you were murdered, your body would mysteriously awaken back to life, naked and whole in your home. In 999 times out of a 1000, those whose lives were intentionally ended by someone else would return to the living like this. No one knows why, no one knows how, no one has any clue what it all means. But what they do know, is that the world is forever changed by this phenomenon.

A good case in point, our protagonist Tony Valdez is a man whose job was created by the government as a result of this new reality. He is a Dispatcher—a trained and licensed professional killer. True, the terms of his position may dictate that he dispatch his clients as quickly and humanely as possible, and there are many rules surrounding his work contracts. But at the end of the day, Tony is aware that his presence is only ever requested when here’s a potential need for him to take a life. For instance, a good number of his assignments involve him being on hand at operating rooms in hospitals, just in case the surgery goes horribly wrong and a patient needs a second chance. In such a situation, Tony would deliver a special “payload” to the dying patient’s brain which would result in their death, essentially murdering them—then BOOM, patient reappears in their home, alive to attempt going under the knife another day.

Of course, not all Dispatchers follow the rules. As someone who used to pick up unofficial and lucrative “private” jobs under the table, Tony knows there are still plenty of his fellow Dispatchers who are doing these illegal gigs on the side. So when one of them goes missing, Tony teams up with a police detective to find out if his colleague’s illicit activities might have led to his disappearance.

With Lock In and now The Dispatcher, I truly think John Scalzi has entered a new phase of his career. While his style has always been quite readable to me, in this book I started to see a new level of polish and elegance in his writing. He seems to have moved past his issue with dialogue tags and the excessive “he saids, she saids”, for one thing. For another, gone is much of the “popcorn humor” his previous books are known for. Though it wouldn’t be fair to say The Dispatcher is completely devoid of levity, for the most part this novella is a very serious endeavor, featuring some thought-provoking yet morbid themes. It may be a short book, but it sure packs a lot of substance.

It’s also clear that much consideration has been put into the concept. While it’s true that the book never ends up giving an explanation for why people who are murdered just start coming back to life, I never really saw that as the point—rather, I looked at The Dispatcher as an interesting thought experiment, and the premise was simply there to provide a framework. What would happen if people couldn’t kill each other anymore? Would it hold people back from their impulses, or would it actually embolden them and make them more reckless, so that we would have secret fight clubs fought with hammers or college kids LARPing in the park with real swords and axes? How might people exploit this new phenomenon, or use Dispatchers to their advantage? What would it do to the world’s views on war, crime, healthcare, religion and pretty much everything in our daily lives? This book explores all these questions and more, touching upon the social effects on a population level, as well as the physical, moral, and psychological implications on a more personal level.

Best of all, woven though all of this is a great story. The Dispatcher gives off vibes of sci-fi crime noire mixed with a little bit of urban fantasy, making it a little tough to categorize, but what comes through strongly is the solid mystery plot. For a novella, I also thought it was very well-paced, with no filler scenes or lulls. All told, the story was riveting from start to finish, making this one a super quick read.

In sum, this is a book I would highly recommend. Even though I love Scalzi’s science fiction and humor, I definitely wouldn’t mind seeing him write more like this, or even expand The Dispatcher universe with future stories since there’s so much potential and possibilities to explore. He has truly created something special here, reminding me once again why he is one of my favorite authors.

25 Comments on “Novella Review: The Dispatcher by John Scalzi”

  1. That is a very different concept for a book…I like that idea. It could be quite mind-boggling to sit and think of all the scenarios and how it could be twisted by people. I think it sounds really interesting. I’ve never read anything by the author as I don’t read much in the genre. Great review!


  2. Scalzi must have had quite the brainstorming session to think of some of the consequences of something like this. Sounds like he’s got a good imagination 🙂


  3. I definitely want to read this. And I agree with your “popcorn humor” description for some of his other books. It’s great that he can write both types, light and humorous and dark and serious.


  4. Hard to define, indeed, and yet the blend of several genres works perfectly. Here Scalzi showed he can write much subtler humor than his usual fare, and I would not mind returning to this world for another story. My experience with The Dispatcher was through the audiobook, read by Zachary Quinto, and I would recommend it to you, since you’re quite comfortable with that medium: his voice sounded perfect for the character, IMHO


    • Yeah, I grabbed the audiobook too back when they did the free promotion for the book. Since it was such a short book, I gave it a listen as well, and also because I was curious about Quinto’s narration. It was indeed excellent!


  5. I’ve heard the synopsis before, but your rendering really brings it to life! I just got The Collapsing Empire in the mail from a giveaway, but The Dispatcher will definitely be next on my Scalzi list 😀 Sounds soo good! Thanks!


  6. I need to read this one! What a cool premise! I’m a little sad that it’s just a novella though. I’ve never tried this author. Sounds like this might be the perfect book to start with.


    • Oh yes, it makes for a great starting on point if you want to try the author! He also has a recent book out called The Collapsing Empire that’s worth check out too if you are curious about his space opera! It’s the first book of a new series 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Hmm this is kind of a neat idea! I think the ramifications of it are fascinating, even if the “why” is never explained. Especially the healthcare and religious ramifications. I’ve been thinking of trying John Scalzi for a while (I just read a review of Redshirts yesterday) and this might be a good place to start.


    • While Redshirts is the book that won the Hugo, I actually enjoy some of his other books a lot more, heh heh 🙂 The Dispatcher would make a good place to start, but also Lock in and Old Man’s War are great! His recent book The Collapsing Empire is quite fun too! Many choices for sure 🙂


  8. Well, I’m two out of two now for Scalzi so I shall definitely pick up more of his books in the future. I really enjoyed Collapsing Empire. This one sounds really fascinating.
    Lynn 😀


  9. Pingback: Mogsy’s Bookshelf Roundup: Stacking the Shelves & Recent Reads | The BiblioSanctum

  10. Pingback: Top Ten Tuesday: Favorite Novellas & Short Story Anthologies | The BiblioSanctum

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: