Book Review: The Night Ocean by Paul La Farge

I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.

The Night Ocean by Paul La Farge

Mogsy’s Rating: 4 of 5 stars

Genre: Historical Fiction, Mystery

Series: Stand Alone

Publisher: Penguin Press (March 7, 2017)

Length: 400 pages

Author Information: Website | Twitter

The Night Ocean is not my usual genre, I confess, but its subject matter was simply too enticing to resist. While it’s true that I’ve always been drawn to books inspired by the writings of H.P. Lovecraft, perhaps just as interesting—if not more so—are the stories about the man himself. A pioneer of weird fiction, his lasting influence on the horror genre can be seen all around us, and yet, there is also a darker side to his legacy. In life, Lovecraft held some repugnant views, and in many fandom circles his racism and bigotry are still discussed almost as much as his work today. Still, love him or hate him, there appears to be a fascination with HPL’s work and personal life which cannot be denied.

Perhaps I should back up a bit, though. While indeed The Night Ocean explores the life of Lovecraft, it does it in a most unconventional and bizarre manner (which I’ll talk more about later), weaving fiction and history into a far-reaching chronicle that also ties in the lives of many other characters. Some of these names will even be familiar to Lovecraft and Horror/SFF aficionados, but first we begin this story with the tragedy of Dr. Marina Willett and her husband Charlie.

It all started with The Erotonomicon. Said to be the erotic diary of H.P. Lovecraft but later claimed to be a hoax, almost all copies are said to be destroyed back in the 50s, but somehow Charlie manages to track one down. As a life-long speculative fiction fan and a writer by trade, Charlie wants to make his next book an investigative piece about the diary, a decision that ends up plunging him into an all-consuming obsession with Lovecraft, much to Marina’s dismay. At the heart of Charlie’s project is a particular entry written in The Erotonomicon about a summer in 1934 involving Lovecraft and his friend Robert Barlow, a gay sixteen-year-old fan with whom the author stayed for a number of weeks while on a visit to Florida. Later known as the author and anthropologist R.H. Barlow, Robert also ended up collaborating with Lovecraft on several stories including “The Night Ocean”, which this book is named for.

Determined to find out the truth about Lovecraft and Barlow’s relationship, Charlie sets out on a continent-spanning journey to find out everything he can about what really happened between the two men that summer in Florida. However, Charlie’s obsession ultimately leads him to his downfall, and after suffering depression and anxiety, he checks himself into a hospital at the urging of his wife. Not long after that, he escapes into the wilderness and disappears without a trace. The note he left made it pretty clear to everyone that Charlie had planned and carried out his suicide, but Marina finds this difficult to accept. Holding on to the belief that her husband is still alive, she retraces his steps for the last two years, going to the places he visited and talking to the people he interviewed for his book, all in the hopes that it will shed some light on where she might find Charlie.

Quite frankly, describing the story any more than this would be a downright nightmare because I would be at an absolute loss as to how to keep going. The Night Ocean is one strange book, difficult to summarize and classify since it is made up of so many perspectives and interconnecting parts. The overall concept behind the novel is certainly ambitious and ingenious, but the way the story is presented will probably make it seem unfocused. Even though the entire book is told through Marina’s eyes, I would say the first half of the book is about Charlie—but also not—while the second half is about Marina—and yet also not. Yes, I’m aware of how confusing this sounds, but really at the heart of both threads is a man named L.C. Spinks, the publisher of The Erotonomicon. Is the diary really a hoax? Or if there’s some truth to it, then which parts of it are real and which parts are completely fabricated? The Night Ocean is an intricately woven web of fact and fiction, combining Paul La Farge’s rich imagination with the results of what must have been hours upon hours of painstaking research on his part.

And how does H.P. Lovecraft play into all this, you ask? Well, last summer I read and really enjoyed a novel called I Am Providence by Nick Mamatas, and even though it and The Night Ocean could not be any more different in tone and style, I still found it impossible not to draw parallels between these two books. Perhaps it is because they are both “Lovecraftian fiction” in the atypical sense; rather than playing directly off of HPL’s large body of works and the mythos he had created, they instead took an almost meta-fiction approach, both narratives coming up with a unique way to explore the author’s life and work through the lens of fandom. After all, one can hardly provide a full picture of Lovecraft’s legacy without recognizing the activities and creations of his highly dedicated fans, a cult following which has been growing since the 40s and 50s—fanzines, conventions, internet clubs and groups, etc. The Night Ocean is a book of many layers and components, and yes, there are parts of the story which deal with the nature of the fan community, presenting both its wonderful and ugly sides.

All told, I had a shockingly good time with this book. Because of its tangled nature, I doubt it going to be for everyone, but still, I highly recommend it if the description interests you. While I found the author’s writing style somewhat quirky and disjointed, I nevertheless managed to get into the rhythm of the story quickly, becoming mesmerized by extraordinary lives of these characters. There’s a lot of pain and heartbreak within these pages, but also a surprising amount of tenderness and beauty that I had not expected to find in a book featuring Lovecraft as a key figure. And even though there’s a lot of ambiguity in the story—a fact that often vexes me—in this case, I believe it might actually add to the book’s mystique.

At once frustrating and rewarding, The Night Ocean is alternate history on a completely new and innovative level. Easily one of the more clever, intense, and haunting books I’ve read so far this year, and its ending will likely stay with me for a long, long time.

25 Comments on “Book Review: The Night Ocean by Paul La Farge”

  1. I’ve never read anything by Lovecraft-and never really wanted to either! I go out of my way to avoid horror books described as Lovecraftian. It wouldn’t be a book I’d want to read but I thought your review was excellent!


  2. I had never even heard of this until I saw it in one of your book hauls, and now I’m intrigued. I’m fascinated by H. P. Lovecraft, even though he had some big issues, and I feel like maybe I would enjoy this.


    • I think there’s a good chance you would! Especially if you’re interested in his history. Like you said, he had some big issues, but there were details of his life that are just downright fascinating, and many of them I found out through reading this book.


  3. I’m glad you enjoyed this one. I found it a super hard book to review. I’ll admit I wasn’t as enamored with it but for some strange reason, I did find it a quick read and hard to put down. I was fine with the ending because it really felt fitting for the book. I think I might have enjoyed it more if I had known more about Lovecraft. Great review.


    • It definitely was a hard book to review! Hard to explain just how weird this book is, like how it’s structured and what goes on, though I did enjoy you couldn’t trust anything 🙂 I can see this one being a real tough book to get into though, just because of the style.


  4. How intriguing, and what a great review. Part of my really wants to read this and part of me doesn’t – I think the part that does will probably win out in the end because I’m fascinating by what you’ve said (and not said).
    Lynn 😀


  5. Your review more than intrigued me: having read a good deal of Lovecraft in the past, I’m curious about a story centered on his life, and at the same time presenting a character who becomes obsessed to the point of madness and suicide like some of HPL’s characters do. I gather that this might be a difficult book, but also a fascinating one – if one can find the right key… 🙂
    Thanks for sharing!


    • As someone who has read a lot of HPL and is familiar with the themes in his work, you will probably find this one fascinating. I didn’t even catch the reference with madness and suicide in his characters, until you mentioned it! I probably missed a lot more from this, wonder how much you could pick up if you read it 🙂


  6. This sounds like a fascinating read, which is shocking for me to say because normally I’m not that into anything Lovecraftian. But any story that explores the darker side of a gargantuan figure like Lovecraft is one that I’m interested in reading, no matter how convoluted it may be!


  7. Pingback: Mogsy’s Bookshelf Roundup: Stacking the Shelves & Recent Reads | The BiblioSanctum

  8. Pingback: Top Ten Tuesday: Top Ten of the Most Unique Books I’ve Read | The BiblioSanctum

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: