A Local Habitation Read-Along Week No.3


We take a trip back to October Daye’s world of mystery and magic in the second book of Seanan McGuire’s October Daye series. If you’re interested in joining this Read-Along, visit the SF/F Read-Along group for more information and to join the discussion.

A Local Habitation

spoiler alert banner

black line 2


Week 1: Saturday 5th March, Chapters 1-8 hosted by Over The Effing Rainbow
Week 2: Saturday 12th March, Chapters 9-16 – hosted by Lynn’s Book Blog
Week 3: Saturday 19th March, Chapters 17-25 – hosted by Books By Proxy
Week 4: Saturday 26th March, Chapters 26-end – hosted by The Bibliosanctum

black line 2

1. First things first, Toby braved the likelihood of being eaten alive by summoning the night-haunts! What are your impressions of this strange race of fae? And how do you think Toby’s relationship with the Luidaeg will change now that her final question has been asked?

Interesting lore, and it makes so much sense. Things like these can sometimes get muddied, but I like where this went with the night-haunts. I feel like this new knowledge Toby has about them will come again in the future. I don’t think that Toby’s relationship with the Luidaeg will actually change. I think pestering Toby to use her last question was just a way of keeping up pretense when she knew she was starting to like Toby. I’m not going to say that she won’t eventually attempt to kill Toby, but I think that, without this façade, the relationship will be seen for what it is, an honest friendship between two women who are an anomaly in the fae world.

2. The storyline has really kicked off with another death to add to the body count and yet another attempt on Toby’s life. How did you feel about this latest murder? Are you suspicious of anyone in particular or seeing any patterns regarding motivations?

I was actually not surprised. It seemed a little inevitable after harebrained theory, but it was sad, especially when thinking of April who doesn’t seem to understand death. This really just makes me dig in more to the fact that Jan, Gordan, and April were likely the guilty parties, especially since Jan was about to spill the beans with the comment she made about want October to come find her so she could explain a thing to her about what’s been going on. After this section, I think April’s part is more guilty by association and omission more than anything, and I am 99.9% certain that Gordan killed Jan, probably to cover up her part in all this, which means she may or may not need to do something about April, too. But I guess I can’t rule out the others also being involved.

3. Before her untimely demise, January was on the verge of revealing a secret regarding ALH and a mysterious project it was running. Do you have any suspicions on what this might be?

Again, I am 99.9% sure that she was going to tell October that she’d been attempting upload her own people to the servers, Gordan had to fabricate the systems making her an accessory, and April was doing whatever it is April does, which is probably just conveniently not knowing certain information to protect Jan. Then again, maybe all her programmers were aware of what was going on. That might’ve been a big undertaking for just three people. So much would need to be done. However, after the first death, I couldn’t see anyone being willing to continue to move forward, so maybe they were forced?

4. April is a fascinating and amusing character to read about, how do you think she’ll cope now she no longer has her adoptive mother? Can you see her becoming part of another court or as an addition to Toby’s life?

In the event she isn’t directly involved in what happened, ALH’s survivors are going to need someone to rally around and rebuild if that’s the route they decide to go. April would know enough about the operations to be that someone with Elliot’s help. She could hold on to Tamed Lightning, and I feel like she would, if she can, for her mother. I think that’s a big possibility especially since this section made such a big point of her being able to handle physical objects–both animate and inanimate–despite her state. That’s if they all don’t turn out to be guilty and aren’t sentenced to like eternity in whatever equates to Hell. I think she’ll mourn, but I think April is logical enough to do what needs to be done and not get caught in her own grief to honor her mother’s memory.

5. In this section of the novel a little more is revealed about one half of our suspicious siblings, Alex and Terrie. Whilst Alex gets very handsy and a bit hypnocreep with Toby, Terrie is almost non-existent! What are your thoughts on this pair? Was Toby’s reaction justified? And are you as suspicious of at least one half of this pairing as Toby?!

I was suspicious of them being the same person early in the story. I got doubly suspicious with Alex seeming to forget he had a “sibling” and then not even offering to call her or something when they have cellphones. Right. People are being murdered and you want me to sit here and believe he wouldn’t attempt to call his sister like immediately. This part pretty much only confirmed that with Elliot saying it was implausible and being on the cusp of the reveal. However, going on the fact that Alex was nowhere near one of the murders, it’s doubtful Alex/Terrie was involved. There might be one wrinkle in time where they’re two people like at dawn or something, but mostly… yeah… Alex seems like the sun and Terrie seems like the moon. I think Toby’s reaction to Alex was justified. I mean no means no. It does’t matter how scared you are. No.

6. Alex might not be able to turn off the seduction but in this section we see the return of both Connor and Tybalt. What do you think of Connor and his obviously complicated relationship with both Toby and Raysel? Do you think they have a future? Or is Tybalt too much of an infuriating temptation? Or more to the point, will either of them be of any use during the investigation? Thoughts please!


The Manicorn as Connor O’Dell. I have rainbows in my heart from looking at this.

I started laughing the minute Connor showed up. I wasn’t really expecting him. Connor is such a manicorn. I need him to go fall out of chairs and bark like a seal somewhere else while my OTP works itself into being. Sheesh. I don’t see Toby and Connor really moving forward. I think there’s familiarity there, and whether they want to admit it or not, Selkie men do have a low-level charm over human women, which Toby is half-human. It may not be as intense as what Alex has going on, and I’m not going to say there whole relationship was probably a lie… but he presses in his own way and she allows it because she used to date him. They could end up together again at the risk of the wrath of Ray, but I kind of doubt it. If it does, it’ll probably go in the “I made a mistake” direction. Been there, done that. I don’t really want to rehash their relationship at this point. I want to see her move forward, but I’m only the reader.

I guess both of guys could be helpful in some way. Tybalt’s already trying to be helpful. He’s already made the cats feel better at least and been relegated to bloodhound. Connor is on babysitting and “Be Mean to Alex” duty, so there’s that.

Additional Thoughts

All the best rituals include blood, amirite? I’ll admit I might got a little misty-eyed when the night-haunt who took Dare’s face said that Toby was her hero. She died still believing in Toby. My emotions.

A manicorn seal, a capricious kitty, and a Quentin puppy walk into a bar…

Favorite Quote

Repetition is sometimes the best way to deal with the Luidaeg: just keep saying the same thing over and over until she gets fed up and gives you what you want. All preschoolers have an instinctive grasp of this concept, but most don’t practice it on immortal water demons. That’s probably why there are so few disembowelments in your average preschool.

* *

“Stop it!” I snapped, before I could stop myself. “That isn’t fair!”

“Since when has death been fair?” The innocence faded from her face, replaced by calm. “Death is how I know you. How we all do.”

* *

 “Quentin, get something nutritious to go with your soda. A Snickers bar or something.” Peanuts have protein, right? Topping off my coffee, I walked over to the pay phone.

* *

black line 2

A Local Habitation by Seanan McGuire (October Daye #2)

A Local Habitation Read-Along Week No.1
A Local Habitation Read-Along Week No.2

Rosemary and Rue by Seanan McGuire (October Daye #1)

Rosemary and Rue Read-Along Week No.1
Rosemary and Rue Read-Along Week No.2
Rosemary and Rue Read-Along Week No.3
Rosemary and Rue Read-Along Week No.4


12 Comments on “A Local Habitation Read-Along Week No.3

  1. Yeah, I don’t see a future for Connor and Toby. That’s in the past and whilst they may have fond memories I’m not feeling it.
    Snickers bars – they are full of protein! And obviously my saying that has nothing to do with all the other gooey goodness or chocolate involved!
    I’m at a loss – I must confess that I didn’t see January dying – but, having read your comments it kind of makes sense that somebody eliminated her before she could spill the beans.
    So happy that Tybalt has arrived on the scene – it feels like finally somebody who can help Toby!
    Love the Manicorn!
    Lynn 😀


    • I like Connor, I do, but it’s like a precious flower walking into the scene when he arrives.

      Jan was probably about to take down her own company by finally telling everyone what was going on, and she paid for it. Her death also seems a bit like a vendetta kill, too. If it does turn out that they’re attempting to upload people, this is a real death for Jan. You may come back from being uploaded, but you’re not coming back from that, which again points at Gordan and her irrational dislike of purebloods.


  2. LOL at the manicorn. Yes! That’s exactly what Connor is. I think he’s so likeable but he doesn’t have the animal attraction of Tybalt! And any relationship with him is likely to end in a whole heap of trouble for Toby.

    Love what you said about the Luidaeg too, I definitely feel that’s the way its going. And April ruling Tamed Lightning – that would be awesome! And so different to all the other courts.


    • I definitely can see April being in charged as the end game for Tamed Lightning after this. If anyone is going to figure out how to bring people back, if anyone has all the intimate knowledge of its workings, it’s April.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Toby and the Luidaeg is and always will be amusing to me, though of course it goes deeper than comedy but I can’t talk about that yet… I long for the day when I can!

    I seem to be on the other side of the line where Connor’s concerned, but hey. We still have Team Tybalt, right? 😀


    • I look forward to seeing where their connections and friendship goes. I figure something deep has to happen with them after the story the Luidaeg gives in the first book.

      #TeamTybalt forever! LOL.


  4. Oh my goodness! The Manicorn!!! (((rolling on the floor in helpless laughter)))
    I guess that my own not-so-charitable feelings for this character are fueling that laughter but really… he feels so *wrong* for Toby, and she should remember there is no going back, ever.


    • He is definitely the Manicorn of the series. I like Connor for right now, but he is slowly starting to move to the bottom of the barrel. I wished he’d just stop.


  5. I think you are right about the friendship between the Luidaeg and Toby. I would like to see it continue for a long time, but since I know this is a long-running series, and shit can happen, who knows if something will eventually break the friendship.

    I’m looking askance at Elliot. I still like Gordon. But we have so few people left I have to wonder now if they all know a piece of it and only one is truly guilty of the killings.

    I’m not too sure April can handle being in charge of Tamed Lightning at this point. She’s so young. On the other hand, she’s a dryad living in a computer system and so I really don’t know what she’s capable of. Can she grow up quickly? Hmmm…

    Love Connor as the manicorn. So true!

    Peanuts do indeed have protein!


    • Yeah, I’m definitely not saying the friendship couldn’t go sour. Right now, I think Toby is safe and their friendship will carry on for a while yet. Connor is the quintessential manicorn of this series. Lol

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: Tiara’s 1st Quarter Update | The BiblioSanctum

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: