#RRSciFiMonth: Echopraxia by Peter Watts

Sci-Fi NovemberSci-Fi November is a month-long blog event hosted by Oh The Books and Rinn Reads this year, created to celebrate everything amazing about science fiction! From TV shows to movies, books to comics, and everything else in between, it is intended to help science fiction lovers share their love and passion for this genre and its many, many fandoms.

EchopraxiaEchopraxia by Peter Watts

Genre: Science Fiction

Series: Book 2 of Firefall

Publisher: Tor (August 26, 2014)

Author Information: Website

Mogsy’s Rating: 3 of 5 stars

I thought I would be going into Echopraxia with two strikes against me. First, the fact that I haven’t read Blindsight which is the first book in the Firefall series, and second, there was the worry that the book would be too “hard sci-fi” for my tastes. Fortunately, neither really ended up being an obstacle. Sure, I had my issues with this novel, but those have little to do with my original concerns.

It’s hard to explain a book like Echopraxia; this is one of those cases where it’s probably better to just let the publisher description do the talking: “The eve of the twenty-second century”, “a world where the dearly departed send postcards back from Heaven and evangelicals make scientific breakthroughs by speaking in tongues”, “genetically engineered vampires solve problems intractable to baseline humans”, “soldiers come with zombie switches that shut off self-awareness during combat”.

It’s a whole other world, with a very different status quo. People like biologist Daniel Bruks who is adamant against upgrading himself with any implants or enhancements are seen as “old school”, living fossils that are still clinging on to an extinct way of life. While working in the field in the middle of the Oregon desert, he finds himself entangled in a conflict between a vampire and her entourage of zombie bodyguards versus a faction of technologically advanced Bicameral monks. Now he’s trapped on a ship headed to the center of the solar system to learn what happened to Blindsight, the expedition which took off years ago to investigate what appeared to be an alien signal.

The ideas here are wild, spectacular and ambitious. The plot, on the other hand, is quite thin – another reason why it would be difficult to describe this novel. Echopraxia is a book that feels less concerned with providing a cohesive narrative, instead focusing more heavily on philosophical discussion and debate on the human condition. Great if like these kinds of books, not so great if you don’t. Personally, I really enjoyed the first hundred pages or so because it contained most of the story. Watts established the setting, the main characters and the conflict. But everything started unraveling after that point, and became unfocused and disorganized.

The challenge for me was in trying to tease apart the jumble of ideas without allowing myself to be driven to distraction. Watts’ writing is laden with scientific jargon and not very easy on the eyes, making this one a slower read. Given the heavier themes and tinge of gloom, not to mention the fact there’s barely any plot, there’s just not too much energy to push it along. Not that I’m saying Echopraxia is a bad book. Far from it, in fact. I feel it has all the right ingredients, but the actual execution of all those great ideas leaves something to be desired.

Over the years, I think I’ve come to gain a deeper appreciation for hard sci-fi. It’s still a struggle sometimes, I admit, but it’s no longer the insurmountable hurdle it once was. However, plot and characters rank high on my priority list. Compelling and cogent storytelling is still somewhat of a requirement in the question of whether or not I’ll enjoy a book. Unfortunately, parts of Echopraxia are just too inconsistent for me to embrace it with open arms, but Watts should be recognized for his incredible talent of making everything he writes about sound fascinating and convincing. This is not a book you’ll want to pick up for a light afternoon of reading, but it’s worth it if you’re up for a thoughtful discourse on the complexities of the human mind and consciousness.


A review copy of this book was provided to me by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. My thanks to Tor Books!

17 Comments on “#RRSciFiMonth: Echopraxia by Peter Watts”

  1. This one made me curious with the synopsis. A friend of mine read it for me but well she wasn’t that happy about it. I’m waiting for her review but I don’t think it’s for me now…


  2. I’ve always avoided Peter Watts for the very reason that he writes hard SF. I’m with you, I would much rather have a nice juicy plot and great characters in my story than listen to an author go on about his beliefs and philosophies. But I sure am intrigued by the world building!


  3. The only time I’ll dive into a series mid-installment is when it’s PNR, otherwise I find that I just feel lost, so good on you for taking a risk. Science Fiction, vampires, and zombies aren’t something that I’d expect to go together, but still, I think this book is too heavy for me.

    Carmel @ Rabid Reads


    • I always scour the internet for information before leaping into as series mid-installment too, which is why reviews from average readers is so, so, so important to me! That’s where I usually get that kind of information!


  4. I’ve tried not once but twice to start “Blindsight”, but in both instances I felt I was not in the right “mood” for it, though I could not understand why: maybe what you stress here – the lack of a focused plot – was at the basis of my difficulties. This second book sounds intriguing though so… I guess your review gave me the incentive to go back and try again!
    Who knows? The third time might be the proverbial charm! 🙂


    • I bought Blindsight because it was on sale, and because the publisher sent me this one and I thought it would be good prep. When I heard that I could just jump into Echopraxia without having read the previous installment, I told myself I can always go back. After this experience though, I’ll probably rethink that 😛


  5. This is a Tor release and I have never heard of it. Fail on my part. But I am not sure I ever trust the ‘second book but it doesn’t matter’ unless it follows different characters.


    • It was on netgalley for a time, but other than that I didn’t see much about it either, aside from the emails the publisher sent me here and there. To be fair, I didn’t think not reading the first book hurt me, it was other things that did. It didn’t follow that many characters, so it was pretty doable on that front.


  6. Not for me probably. I think I’ll go for a nice gentle sci fi – being such a newbie on the block! Anyway, I refuse to read a book where the title alone makes me feel thick (:D)
    Lynn 😀


  7. You hit the nail exactly on the head with Peter’s writing style I think because this ” less concerned with providing a cohesive narrative, instead focusing more heavily on philosophical discussion and debate on the human condition. ” is similar to how I felt about his book of short stories BEYOND THE RIFT.

    Finding the story in the jumble of all the complex ideas could sometimes be a challenge and those were short stories so I knew that I’d have a harder time with a full length novel of his. Though I did think many of the shorts were pretty brilliant.


    • Oh interesting! I didn’t know he had a book of shorts and that you’d read it. I would have totally hit you up for your opinion before starting this if I’d known!


  8. Hearing that your appreciation for hard sci-fi has grown over the years gives me hope! At this point I consider hard sci-fi a no fly zone (pun intended) and tend to avoid it, especially if it seems overly science-y. But I can forgive anything for great characters! Sounds like Echophraxia is not the place for me to start, haha.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: