Guest Post: “A Three-Headed Monster: Mixing Crime Fiction, Horror, and Urban Fantasy” by Jamie Schultz

We’re very pleased to welcome Jamie Schultz, author of Premonitions, to The BiblioSanctum today! In case you missed it, be sure to check out the reviewPremonitions is cool, deliciously dark, and definitely not your average urban fantasy, and we’re gonna find out why. Take it away, Jamie!

A THREE-HEADED MONSTER: MIXING CRIME FICTION, HORROR, AND URBAN FANTASY
By Jamie Schultz

PremonitionsMy book, Premonitions, is kind of an odd duck. It’s urban fantasy, certainly, but it’s got hardboiled crime fiction spliced into its DNA, and it was raised on a steady diet of horror until it grew up and became the strange beast it is today. I’ve written elsewhere about what urban fantasy, crime fiction, and horror have in common—in my mind, they are each aspects of what I call the literature of hidden worlds—but not so much about the unique contributions each genre has made to Premonitions (and, arguably, to my writing style and focus in general).

Premonitions is, at heart, a heist novel. It takes place in the occult flipside of Los Angeles’s criminal underworld, and there are supernatural goings-on galore, but the core of the story is a rather bizarre heist and its aftermath. I doubt it’s much of a spoiler to reveal that the heist doesn’t go quite as planned (do they ever?), so we’ll just take that as a given.

So, given all the ways to approach urban fantasy, why a heist? I like a good heist story for a couple of reasons. The first is that, traditionally, they will involve an unusual mix of characters, each with their own particular contribution to make to the team. In her review of the book, Mogsy talked about that as part of the draw of these types of stories for her, and it’s a big part of the draw for me, too. I like seeing how the people in a team fit together and complement one another, whether that’s DeNiro’s team of crooks from Heat, the ex-CIA guys from The Losers, or even the freaking A-team. There’s a lot of opportunity for chemistry there, and that can be a ton of fun.

The other reason I like the mix of characters is for the opportunity to look at a range of character motivations. Let’s face it, you gotta have some pretty good reasons to get into a dangerous life of crime, and having a crew of crooks, each with their own motivation, not only provides an interesting glimpse into that, but it offers opportunity for conflict where those motivations rub together, even on the most tightly-knit team (witness trying to get B.A. Baracus on an airplane, for a particularly silly example of that). In Premonitions, each of the crew has their own motivation—Karyn’s desperate to pay for the drug that keeps her sane, Anna is determined to stick with her friend, Nail needs the cash to keep his brother out of trouble, and Tommy is darkly fascinated with the occult and all its trappings. Part of the interest for me is watching how those motivations direct their actions.

And, of course, the last draw of the heist story is the inevitable disaster. It’s a given in virtually every heist story that the job will go pear-shaped at some point, either during the execution or in the aftermath—and, frankly, I have a morbid fascination with watching things come apart.

It’s almost scary how naturally the urban fantasy and horror elements slotted in place once I’d decided on the heist framework. Somebody who read an early draft of the book made a comment about how, instead of the crew having to sneak past a laser tripwire, they have a freaking terrifying demon to contend with, and I thought the statement particularly apt. The function is the same, but the flavor is dramatically different, which is part of the fun.

Another reason the horror elements crept in has to do with the overall mood. The characters are criminals, operating in a conjoined criminal/occult underworld, and as such, the story pulls pretty heavily from some of its hardboiled and noir influences. There are lots of uses the supernatural is put to in literature, but I like to use it as an intensifier—it helps heighten contrasts or reinforce existing themes. For example, magic is not a very nice thing in the world of Premonitions, explicitly fueled by demonic forces, and the occult underworld is a heightened reflection of the criminal underworld in the book. In the case of both criminal activity and meddling with occult forces, you may get something you want right now, but it’s risky, and there’s a very good chance you’ll pay dearly for it later. I liked the way those two elements played off each other, and I tried to reinforce that every chance I got.

At some level, though, dissecting one’s own book is more of an exercise in after-the-fact diagnosis than an accurate depiction of where the book came from. I can see how the bits fit together now, in hindsight, and there are some definite places where that was more deliberate than incidental, but overall I ended up with this unusual combination of genres more because it felt right than anything else. I read a lot of crime fiction and horror, and drawing on those influences felt as natural as breathing. I liked the way urban fantasy works with the two. The book ends up being a bit of a departure from most urban fantasy—a little darker, a little less heroic—but maybe a little more earthy because of it.

I think it works, and, maybe more importantly, I had a great time writing it.

* * *

jamie_schultz_pictureABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jamie Schultz has worked as a rocket test engineer, an environmental consultant, a technical writer, and a construction worker, among other things. He lives in Dallas, Texas. His first novel, Premonitions, received a starred review from Library Journal, who called it “a sterling urban fantasy debut with a great cast of characters.”

Sunday Musings: Giving Thanks

This is Thanksgiving weekend in Canada. There are many things I am thankful for, including a new job. It’s tying up a lot of my time, which means I have less time for reading, writing, and gaming, but so far, the trade off has been worth it. Hopefully I can find myself a new groove to settle into that will let me balance things out again.

galaxy gameCURRENTLY READING
The Best of All Possible Worlds snuck up on me. The quiet little romance set in the distant future, on a distant planet, cuddled up beside me on the couch and got right under my skin.  When I learned Karen Lord had written a sequel, I was very excited. And now, thanks to NetGalley, The Galaxy Game my current read!

WRITERY THINGS
“Structure is important,” writes Peter James. “Know your ending before you start writing.”

I agree with the former, but not with the latter. I definitely like working with a structure when I start writing, and have elaborate outlines spelled out before I settle in to the story. But more often than not, the conclusion is the last thing (no pun intended) I manage to think of. If I held myself to James’ rule of not starting before I know the ending, then I would write very little indeed.

BOOKISH THOUGHTS
ac77d91a4e26abf7ed831f4c57c821af

 

Lootz: Mogsy’s Book Haul

Welcome to this biweekly feature where I showcase all the books I bought/won/received for review in the past fortnight. First, the physical pile:

book haul 9

The Seventh SigilThird book to the Dragon Brigade trilogy which showed up unexpectedly from Tor, and was waiting for me when I returned from my trip out of town a couple weeks ago. Unfortunately I haven’t read the first two books, but there’s a good chance I may go back to read them. My thanks to the publisher.

Poison Fruit – I’m so excited to read this; I’m a big fan of Jacqueline Carey and her urban fantasy series Agent of Hel has been a lot of fun so far. I hear this is the third and final book, and I’m looking forward to see how it ends.

Stories of the Raksura – I was pretty psyched when Night Shade Books sent this one along. I’ve wanted to read Martha Wells’ Books of the Raksura books for a long time! Not sure if jumping right into this novella collection is going to be a good idea because I’m afraid I might get lost, but I’m going to give it a shot anyway.

Elisha Barber – A purchase from the wonderful Book Outlet. I had a coupon for them from a while back, and decided to get a whole bunch of books for my daughter with it (because children’s books can be so expensive elsewhere!) and I just couldn’t help tossing in something for myself.

Unholy War – This was another precious gem that was waiting for me when I got home from my road trip. I just finished the second book of the Moontide Quartet (be sure to keep an eye out for my review of Scarlet Tides next week!) and so I was thrilled to see that Jo Fletcher Books had sent me book three. I’m definitely not going to wait as long to read this one!

And speaking of The Moontide Quartet, book two Scarlet Tides was also just released in the US with a similar looking cover than the UK, except in beautiful hardback. And I do mean beautiful. I was sent this edition courtesy of Quercus USA and Wunderkind PR, and I just wanted to show it side by side with my US HC of the first book Mage’s Blood to marvel at that amazing detail and embossment.

MoontideNo new eARCs while I’m still on my self-imposed digital galleys ban, at least until I can chisel down my NetGalley TBR. But I do have a couple books to feature for the digital pile:

The Messenger  The Scorched Earth  The Assassin's Blade

The Messenger – Last year a great book came out from Tor UK called Drakenfeld. Unfortunately, still no US release date yet, and the sequel Retribution is already on the horizon. The Messenger is a short story set in that world, and I was actually surprised to see it available for US Kindle, so of course I grabbed it.

The Scorched Earth – I’ll probably never be able to finish all the ebooks I’ve ever bought, and I’ve come to accept that. But there’s a better chance I’ll get to them if I buy the audiobook. This has been sitting on my to-read list for a while, and I saw there was a good Whispersync deal, and added the audio version for ~$3.

The Assassin’s Blade – Got this audiobook as another cheap Whispersync deal. After the great time I had with Heir of Fire, I’ve decided to take the plunge on the short story anthology for this series. I don’t usually do that, but I heard The Assassin’s Blade was great, and that I should make an exception for this collection!

 

 

Novella Review: The Broken Road by Teresa Frohock

The Broken RoadThe Broken Road by Teresa Frohock

Genre: Dark Fantasy, Science Fiction

Series: Frayed Empire #1

Publisher: The Story Vault (September 2014)

Author Info: www.tfrohock.com

Wendy’s Rating ~ 5 of 5 stars.

Kill it. With fire.

One of my biggest complaints in fantasy and science fiction is the way far too many authors can’t seem to let go of the sexism that plagues our reality. What I love about Frohock’s writing is that she gives me a world I want to see: a world of diverse characters who aren’t judged by the things that I have to deal with on a day to day basis.

Not that the characters in The Broken Road don’t deal with prejudice and hate. The aristocracy have little love for the “groties,” the physically challenged lowborn that they lord over. Our protagonist, Prince Travys, suffers his own challenges, being born mute–which makes life difficult for him as a Chanteuse, the magic users who hold the threads of their world together.

Unique forms of magic always appeal to me. The Chanteuse use their voices to weave their magic, ranging from a few words, to beautiful, haunting melodies that I can almost hear as I read. The magic is unique, as is the way Travys’ overcomes his disability by drawing sound from his environment.

As the story unfolds, we learn that Travys’ mother, the Queen, intends him to marry his twin brother’s lover and rule as king. But there is more to this than politics and sibling rivalry. The lowborn have resurrected the dead god, and a strange, corrupted magic is seeping into cracks between the world of Lehbet and Heled on the other side, which Travys is forced to travel to when his brother betrays him.

This is where the story gets *really* interesting, as Frohock smoothly blends her worlds of fantasy, horror and…. flamethrowers.

Everything’s better with fire…
39dec-5stars

Tough Traveling: Dark Ladies

3bfd8-toughtraveling

The Thursday feature “Tough Traveling” is the brainchild of Nathan ofReview Barn, who has come up with the excellent idea of making a new list each week based on the most common tropes in fantasy, as seen in The Tough Guide to Fantasyland by Diana Wynn Jones. Nathan has invited anyone who is interested to come play along, so be sure to check out the first link for more information. Compulsive list-maker that I am, I’m very excited to take part!

This week’s tour topic is: DARK LADY

DARK LADY. There is never one of these – so see DARK LORD instead:

(There is always one of these in the background of every Tour, attempting to ruin everything and take over the world  He will be so sinister that he will be seen by you only once or twice, probably near the end of the Tour…)

Mogsy’s Picks:

Dang, I think I might have used up a couple of my Dark Ladies for Dark Lord week, but let me dig a little deeper into my shelves and see what I can come up with. One or two of these might be a stretch; like the description suggests, there are relatively few of these compared to their male counterparts…

Mage's BloodMage’s Blood by David Hair

Sainted Mater-Empress Lucia, mother of Emperor Constant, takes the top spot for evilness in this series, pulling the strings behind the scenes and juggling her network of cronies, essentially making her own son her puppet. The extent of said evilness wasn’t made apparent until the second book which I just read recently, but now that we know more, up she goes on this list.

StormrageStormrage by Richard A. Knaak

A prominent character in the Warcraft video games, Sylvanas Windrunner actually styles herself as “the Dark Lady” or “the Banshee Queen” after being transformed into an undead and becoming supreme ruler of the Forsaken faction. She appears here and there in the World of Warcraft series of novels. In Stormrage, Sylvanas dreams about being a high elf once again while under the twisted effects of Emerald Nightmare.

A World Without PrincesA World Without Princes by Soman Chainani

The main characters Sophie and Agatha return to the School for Good and Evil in this sequel to find that everything they knew about their fairy tale world has changed. A new villain is introduced in the form of Evelyn Sader, the new dean who has taken over the school and rules it with an iron fist, using her butterflies as innocuous seeming spies to keep all the professors and students in check.

Summer KnightSummer Knight by Jim Butcher

Mab is the Faerie Queen of the Winter Court, also called the Queen of Air and Darkness — that’s close enough to a Dark Lady for me! She makes her first appearance in this book. Easily one of the most powerful beings in the Dresden Files series, Mab is ruthless and moments of compassion from her are very rare.

CinderThe Lunar Chronicles by Marissa Meyer

Queen Levana of Luna is the main villain of the series, who came upon her throne by starting a fire in the palace nursery, killing her own sister and supposedly her niece. She is greatly feared by her people, due to her extremely powerful glamor abilities that can make anyone submit to her instantly, which is why no one has ever been able to oppose or overthrow her.

Book Review: Dust and Light by Carol Berg

Dust and LightDust and Light by Carol Berg

Genre: Fanasy

Series: Book 1 of The Sanctuary Duet

Publisher: Roc (August 5, 2014)

Author Information: Website

Mogsy’s Rating: 3.5 of 5 stars

This is my first book by Carol Berg so I wasn’t sure what to expect. But as the start of a new series taking place in the world of her Lighthouse novels, I figured Dust and Light was a pretty good place for me to start. I ended up being very impressed with her world building, especially when it came to the conceptual framework for her magic, which I found wonderfully enticing and beautiful. However, I also thought the story’s pacing was rather shaky throughout, with things coming a bit undone towards the end, otherwise I would have given this book a higher rating.

Dust and Light introduces us to Lucian de Remeni-Masson, a young Pureblood from a noble house. A Pureblood’s magical talent is called a “bent”, and Lucian, being somewhat of an oddity, has two of them. After landing in hot water over a dalliance with an Ordinary woman, Lucian’s grandfather attempted to have one of his bents burned out, and Lucian ends up working as an artist painting portraits under the supervision of the Pureblood Registry. But then Harrowers set the Remeni-Masson estate afire, killing the whole family save for Lucian and his younger sister Juli.

Not having reached the age to inherit the title as head of his house, Lucian’s life is now in the hands of the Registry. When his contract is sold to a common coroner, he is forced to apply his artistic gifts towards painting portraits of the dead for the purposes of identification. But his magic leads to revelations in his art, and one day, while sketching the corpse of a young murdered girl, the resulting portrait points to the victim as being more than just an Ordinary common child. In trying to uncover the truth with his contract holder Bastien, Lucian quickly becomes embroiled in a storm of conspiracy and politics.

As an artist myself, how could I not find Lucian immediately intriguing? Even his new job of sketching faces of the dead is delightfully morbid and fascinating in its own way. The magic behind his talent and how it manifests itself is a strange but wondrous power, leading to a premise that was filled to the brim with potential. And in fact, I did very much enjoy the first part of the book. Bastien the coroner and investigator is a prickly master, but together he and Lucian make for a good team. It was the perfect set up for an excellent fantasy-mystery.

But for all that the plot remained swift and full of thrills, I thought the overall story was hindered by too many ideas and multiple side threads jostling for attention, which ends up doing a number on the book’s pacing. These elements may work well individually, but I feel the Berg falters here and there when attempting to incorporate everything together while maintain a balance; I felt pulled this way and that, which was quite distracting. It’s important to note that the novel is also divided into several parts, and we lose some time between the first and second when Lucian ends up landing in a bit of trouble with the Registry. As transitions go, it had the effect of a speed bump, and I think that was when I hit my first stumbling block.

Like I mentioned before, I also wasn’t too fond of the ending, which I thought was rushed and so in the process we lose a lot of the mystery and intrigue. I would have preferred a greater emphasis on the investigation side of the story, but of course Lucian’s personal plight and finding out the answers behind his murdered family played a large part too. If you prefer books that are more character-focused (as I do) then you’re sure to enjoy this one. Lucian is brought low, but gradually climbs his way back up to take charge of his life in this extraordinary tale of a young man on a journey of self-discovery.

Even though the execution of this wasn’t as clean as I would have liked, I can’t deny this book had its moments – more positive ones than negative. I think Dust and Light was a good introduction for me to the author’s work. Something tells me this series is just warming up, and the best is still to come in the second half of this duet.

90b91-new3-5stars

A review copy of this book was provided to me by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. My thanks to Roc Books!

Waiting on Wednesday 10/08/14

“Waiting On Wednesday” is a weekly meme hosted by Breaking the Spine that lets us feature upcoming releases that we can’t wait to get our hands on!

Mogsy’s Pick:

Jinn and Juice by Nicole Peeler: November 25, 2014 (Orbit)

A few weeks ago, Orbit posted a reveal/launch of their spring to summer 2015 covers, and there’s a lot of good stuff there. Presumably some of them are paperback releases because there are some titles there we’ve already seen before. This is one I must have missed the first time around, because apparently it’s slated to be out at the end of this November. I can’t say I’ve read a lot of urban fantasy featuring Djinn/Jinni/Genies, so this one automatically captured my attention. The fuchsia cover, the “Don’t rub me the wrong way” tagline and belly dancing…heck, I find myself intrigued, in spite of myself.

Jinn and Juice“Cursed to be a jinni for a thousand years, Leila nears the end of her servitude—only to be bound once again against her will. Will she risk all to be human?

Born in ancient Persia, Leila turned to her house Jinni, Kouros, for help escaping an arranged marriage. Kouros did make it impossible for her to marry—by cursing Leila to live a thousand years as a Jinni herself.

If she can remain unBound, Leila’s curse will soon be over. But Ozan Sawyer, a Magi with the ability to See, Call, and Bind jinn has other plans. Oz needs Leila to help him penetrate Pittsburgh’s steel-soaked magic, a juice potent but poisonous to supernatural creatures, in order to find a missing girl with her own mysterious connection to Kouros. Unfortunately for Leila, becoming Bound to Oz may risk more than just her chance to be human once more—it could risk her very soul…

Jinn and Juice is the first in a new series by fantasy writer, Nicole Peeler, set in a world of immortal curses, powerful jinni and belly dancing.”

Guest Post: “In Defense of Fluff and Fun” by Erin Lindsey

You may have caught our review (and GIVEAWAY too!) of The Bloodbound last week, and today we are excited to have author Erin Lindsey on board to talk discuss the novel and her approach to world-building. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did, and if you haven’t checked out our giveaway yet, there’s still time! It is an excellent book with its perfect mix of fantasy and romance, and not to be missed.

IN DEFENSE OF FLUFF AND FUN
by Erin Lindsey

Recently, I came across an article by Justin Landon on Tor.com [http://www.tor.com/blogs/2014/09/book-review-the-broken-eye-brent-weeks] that made me sit up and say Yes.

IThe Bloodboundn fact, it made me sit up and say something a little more emphatic than that, but I’m trying to keep it PG here.

The post was primarily a review of THE BROKEN EYE by Brent Weeks. The part that made me sit up and take notice, though, was this:

The frustration I have … is [the suggestion that] there’s something wrong with pulp, and that epic fantasy should necessarily have some larger agenda. … Is it enough to merely entertain? I believe this argument is at the core of a lot of criticism that surrounds epic fantasy.”

I couldn’t agree more, and in fact I’d extend the argument to SF/F in general. Somewhere along the line, it has become a virtual truism in speculative fiction that it isn’t enough merely to tell a good story. A book might be wildly entertaining, but if it isn’t tackling some Big Issue, then it falls short. At the very least, it should challenge genre tropes, subvert expectations, dazzle us with meticulous research and thought-provoking what ifs. It should be meaningful.

The thing is, I don’t buy that. In fact, I think it’s rubbish.

I admire a complex, thought-provoking tale as much as the next person. Guy Gavriel Kay’s TIGANA made me want to hang ‘em up forever, because there was just no way I could ever craft something that brilliant. The commentary on the importance of identity and control of the historical narrative… it resonated so much with me. But you know what? I’ve had just as much fun reading what Landon refers to as “charismatic fluff” – and I’m not ashamed of it. Where is written that SF/F has to be cerebral to be good?

I have a similar attitude when it comes to world-building. One of my biggest pet peeves as a reader of fantasy is gratuitous world-building – “gratuitous” being the operative word here. World-building is a necessary – and wonderful – feature of the genre. But there is a fine line between adding depth and texture and indulging in unnecessary flourishes that don’t actually enhance the story in any meaningful way. Do I really need to know the two hundred year backstory of the hero’s family estate? Is it important to the plot that the spiced mutton being served at this meal is stewed in cherries because that’s the way King Unpronouncablename decreed it must be prepared during the Reign of Terror and it’s been like that ever since? Do I need the entire theology of the world to be crammed into Book 1 of the series? I love it when these kinds of details are folded in gradually and elegantly, in ways that enhance the story. Too often, though, they’re a detour, a scenic route taken not for the reader, but for the author, just to show that s/he’s thought it through. As a writer, I certainly understand the impulse – you’ve created a three dimensional world, and you want to show it off – but as a reader, I often find it disruptive. It doesn’t enrich the story, but intrudes on it. At worst, it can come off as self-indulgent and boring.

So how much is too much? I think it comes down to taste. As with descriptive language, romance, and so many things, some like a heavier hand, some a lighter touch. Somehow, though, it seems as if elaborate world-building, like thought-provoking themes, has become a requirement for the genre, a once-size-fits-all criterion against which all contenders will be measured. I think that’s a shame.

No surprise, then, that as an author, I tend towards minimalism. With THE BLOODBOUND, I made a conscious effort to focus on characters rather than magic systems and religions and backstory. I didn’t have a Message, and the themes I’m playing with are certainly not new. As it says in my author bio, I wanted to create the perfect summer vacation novel. I wasn’t out to re-invent the wheel – just to make it the shiniest, fastest, most entertaining wheel it could be. Because for my money, those sorts of books are often the most enjoyable.

Your mileage may vary. But that’s the beauty of speculative fiction – it’s all about variety.

Or at least, it should be.

* * *

ed119-e-l-tettensorABOUT THE AUTHOR

Erin Lindsey is on a quest to write the perfect summer vacation novel, with just the right blend of action, heartbreak, and triumph. The Bloodbound is her first effort. She lives and works in Bujumbura, Burundi, with her husband a pair of half-domesticated cats.

Graphic Novel Review: All-Star Superman by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely

All-Star SupermanAll-Star Superman, Vol. 1 by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely

Genre: Superheroes

Publisher: DC Comics (2007)

Author Info: www.grant-morrison.com

Artist Info: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Quitely

Wendy’s Rating: 4 of 5 stars

Poor Superman is always going to start off on the wrong foot with me and having him written by Grant Morrison doesn’t make things much better. Fortunately, I’ve read Morrison’s We3, where he lets Quitely’s art do what it’s supposed to do: tell the story–so I expected to see as much here. Secondly, Morrison’s approach to this series pleased me, as he stated in the planning stages that he did not want to rehash Superman’s origin story yet again. The point of All-Star Superman is to give us the essence of the character, which is what I have been looking for all this time.

Superman fans who have seen my low ratings of other tales such as Superman: Birthright and Superman: Earth One, while I praise alternate, darker visions of the characters like Superman: Red Son and Lex Luthor: Man of Steel, probably think I’m trolling. What I have actually been doing in my readings is trying understand why people like this character that just doesn’t make sense to me. “He’s one of us,” is something that I’ve been told many times, but I just can’t buy it. He’s a god disguising himself as a human. That’s not fitting in. That’s just damn good acting. “But you read stories about people who command the weather and shoot laser beams out of their eyes,” people argue. I sure do, but for me, the X-Men have always been human beings first. The world as a whole might hate them from time to time, but the X-stories have always given the mutants a place to belong within their own community. They always have a place where they can be themselves, without pretending. Meanwhile, Superman fans have tried to convince me that Kal’El is the very same. Certainly he wants that, but how can he ever have that when he is completely alien? Yes, he has moments of weakness thanks to kryptonite where he gets to experience life as a weak little human being for a few days, but he always gets his powers back so he can save the day. That’s not quite a mile in my shoes, Clark.

But All-Star Superman addresses many of my concerns, sometimes in very amusing ways. Most notably, the concept of no one recognizing Clark as Superman. I like that Morrison and Quitely actually change his physical appearance beyond hair and glasses. Here, Clark is a little bit overweight, to go along with his cowardly, clutzy demeanor. And when he reveals himself to Lois, the Pulitzer prize winning investigative report, and even Lex, the most brilliant mind in the world, no one can fathom that they are one and the same, even if there is a striking resemblance. I love the way Morrison/Quitely really play up the concept of mind over matter, letting even the most intuitive minds only see what they want to see.

All-Star Superman | DC ComicsI keep saying that I want a well-written Superman story that helps me to appreciate the character, even though I may never like him. This is it. In fact, it is the Superman story I should have read first and just skipped all of these origin stories that try to tell a “new” story despite being forever forced into the Superman standards of Daily Planet, Krypton, Ma and Pa Kent, Lois Lane, Lex Luthor, etc etc. By shedding the need for these chains, while still working on the assumption that I am fully aware of them, Morrison/Quitely just give me a look at the Man of Steel himself. The lonely man who is loved and hated by those around him. A man who understands that dichotomy, and recognizes that can never be one of us, no matter how much he cares for humanity. Morrison and Quitely aren’t asking me to love him too, or even respect him. They are just presenting him as he is. It’s up to me to take him or leave him.

At the end of the day, I don’t like the character, but I can appreciate this “just shut up and Superman” story as a fine example of who and what he is.

ab28c-new4stars

YA Weekend: Daughter of Smoke & Bone by Laini Taylor

4c87c-daughterofsmokeandboneDaughter of Smoke & Bone by Laini Taylor

Genre: Young Adult, Supernatural, Romance, Urban Fantasy

Series: Daughter of Smoke & Bone #1

Publisher: Little Brown Books (September 2011)

Author Info:  www.lainitaylor.com

Wendy’s Rating: 3 of 5 stars

Karou is a nice, blue-haired enigma living in Prague and attending art school where her friends love to see her sketchbooks. In those books are beautiful images of fantastical creatures–human and beast, woven together like tapestries–and she has elaborate tales to go with every image on every page.

The thing is, the stories she tells about those creatures are as real as the creatures themselves, because Karou’s family happen to be a bunch of chimera. Karou is well aware that this is not exactly normal, but, having no clue about anything else about herself, she accepts it as how her life works. Until the angels arrive to literally burn things down.

Taylor’s world is incredible, and I love the tantalizing unveiling of the age-old struggle between the chimera and the angels, with neither side clearly being good or evil and poor Karou caught in the middle of it. The only thing that could make this aspect of the book better is if it included a full gallery of Karou’s work.

Unfortunately, the story starts to fall apart for me right about the time that the angel Akiva appears. He is beautiful beyond all understanding, and Karou is drawn to him as he is to her, even though they are enemies. Uh oh. Forbidden love alarm bells! I love a good Romeo and Juliet story, but this one just wasn’t it. When the two start to obviously fall for each other, the feisty Karou is replaced by the lonely Karou in desperate need of someone to call her own, while Akiva, who gets to tell the story from his own point of view as well, is the wounded angel who once knew the love of the enemy and is falling for it again.

Back to the part about the angels burning things down. The book takes on all the signs of a pending apocalypse when the angels reveal themselves to humanity, fighting this battle on earth instead of in other realms as it has been in the past. While we do get a few glimpses of the damage and excitement that results, that all becomes background noise as Akiva and Karou go on dates to get to know each other. Okay, it’s not that trite, but it feels a bit like that at times when they are hanging out at coffee houses after epic street battles–even if the people do believe it to be just an elaborate street performance.

Once we learn about Akiva’s past, the connection to Karou becomes obvious and so the big reveal–which is dragged out to frustrating levels–isn’t such a surprise. It’s also where the book falters further, slowing the pace to give us the truth about Karou in more forbidden love angst, complete with potential love triangle concerns.

By the end, I was disappointed. So much potential in a unique story about angels and demons and their war, but it all just ends up as a banal young adult love story. Despite the second big reveal (again, dragged out and unsurprising), there is promise for things to get interesting, but I have so little desire to hang out with Karou and Akiva much further.

758dc-new3stars