Book Review: A Longer Fall by Charlaine Harris
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
A Longer Fall by Charlaine Harris
Mogsy’s Rating: 3.5 of 5 stars
Genre: Urban Fantasy, Paranormal
Series: Book 2 of Gunnie Rose
Publisher: Saga Press (January 14, 2020)
Length: 304 pages
Author Information: Website | Twitter
I’ve been looking forward to this second book of the Gunnie Rose series for a long time—after all, I loved An Easy Death and couldn’t wait for round two with Lizbeth, our badass gunslinging protagonist who makes a living as a mercenary in a post-apocalyptic, western-inspired alternate version of the United States. That said, I’m glad I kept my expectations somewhat in check, because A Longer Fall was probably not what it could have been. Entertaining, yes, but I wouldn’t say it takes the story or characters to the next level the way a sequel should.
When our story begins, Lizbeth has just signed on with another crew to escort a convoy and its cargo from Texoma to a town called Sally in Dixie. It was supposed to be a routine job, but enroute to their destination, their train was ambushed, many travelers were killed, and a precious crate with its mysterious contents was stolen. Her employer dead and her friends gravely injured, Lizbeth sets off on a mission to hunt down their attackers and discover what it was they stole that was important enough to kill for. That, and she’ll need to recover the box and make an actual delivery in order to get paid.
With the arrival of Eli Savarov, a grigori wizard from the Holy Russian Empire—and Lizbeth’s sort-of old fling—she knows she’s on to something big. Turns out Eli already knows about the missing crate, and he’s in town to find it too. Teaming up, the two of them pose as a married couple to investigate, Sally not being the kind of conservative place to tolerate a single, unaccompanied woman poking her nose around in their business. In fact, the town isn’t really too tolerant of anything, with sexism and racism very much alive and well in its people.
And well, that’s really all there is to the story. Up until the final few chapters, we mostly follow Lizbeth and Eli around town as they try to turn up any clues about the stolen cargo. Considering how dazzled I was by the setting in the first book, seeing so little of it this time around was a bit disappointing, and it was due to the limited scope of the story. While good sequels tend to build upon previous books, further developing the advancing the overarching plot of the series and its characters, A Longer Fall keeps us mainly in a holding pattern. In a way, it feels lacking in its “sequel status” and comes across half-hearted.
Speaking of which, I just didn’t feel whatever it was that was supposed to be between Lizbeth and Eli. Their relationship was downright bizarre, and calling it a romance doesn’t feel quite right. Hardly a chapter can go by without us being constantly reminded that the two of them have no future, even as they go at each other like rabbits. If there was supposed to be some tension, I just didn’t feel it. And I kept waiting, hoping that their strange dynamic would build up to something worthwhile, and well…I won’t spoil how things turn out, but let’s just say I was far from satisfied.
Then there was the ending, which felt so incongruous that I could probably take up a whole page just describing how surreal it all felt. First was the crate. Funny enough, I had been forewarned by other reviewers about this, but apparently I was still inadequately prepared because I literally let out a snort of incredulity the moment Lizbeth was confronted with the contents of the crate for the first time. Even more random was the novel’s overall resolution. After spending nearly three hundred pages with all manner of violent and brutal characters in this merciless blood-soaked world, I suddenly felt like I was thrust into the middle of one of my kids’ PBS cartoons. Just a really weird, jarring way to tie everything up.
And yet, despite what might seem like my trashing of the novel, I don’t want to make it sound like I didn’t enjoy myself or that this was a bad book. Because it wasn’t, really! I had a good time with it, and it was a fast read—perfect for when you’re in the mood for something mindlessly light and fluffy, perhaps.
Thing is, I had expected something a little more substantial. A Longer Fall didn’t quite deliver in that sense, mostly coming across like “just another book in a series” but it was still very entertaining, and at no time did I feel like it wasn’t worth reading or that it was wasting my time. To be honest, I actually had a lot of fun with the story, even if it meant a few chortles at its expense. At the end of the day though, I’m looking forward to more of Gunnie Rose and here’s hoping the next book will have more oomph.
More on The BiblioSanctum:
Review of An Easy Death (Book 1)
It’s great that you enjoyed it, at least! Mostly I just remember the ending, and how it sucked and was terrible.
It was pretty random and jarring. I didn’t hate it, but I was pretty put off, lol.
Okay so now I’m officially scared. Both you and Tammy have been let down by this sequel and I waited for it forever and want to love it so much. I have it out from my library and thank heavens I was just able to renew it. There’s no way I can work it in during February but I think I can in early March. Great review and at least you enjoyed it so there’s that. However, I anticipated it being a 5/5 read for me!
Well, as long as you’re prepared, it might not be that bad! And it wasn’t like this was a terrible book – I enjoyed it! Just brace yourself for some strangeness in the ending, and you should be fine, lol!
You summed up my feelings almost exactly. Ugh that ending! It was such a bizarre 180 that I literally had to reread parts to make sure I got it right. But still, I am invested and I do want to continue the series.
Yeah, even with all the reviews I read talking about the weird ending, I was not prepared!
There is the dreaded “second book syndrome” and there is also “second book fright” and from your description it would seem that the author fell prey to the latter here, keeping to much-too-safe ground and not trying to “cash in” from the previous success. Still, it seems to have been an entertaining read, so there’s that at least… 😉
Yep, let’s just hope “second book syndrome” doesn’t extend to the next book – I had so much hope for this series, I’d hate to see it fizzle!
I enjoyed book 1 and I was curious about this one!
I hope you’ll enjoy it!
I am curious about book 1…one day!
I loved book 1! This one…well, it was good, but definitely not as awesome 🙂
I think I will probably still continue with this but it is a bit discouraging that this isn’t as good as the first – maybe just second book syndrome or maybe it’s not going to be the sort of series we were expecting – we’ll find out with the third book I suppose
I think as long as you’re prepared, you’ll be fine. I did have a good time with this one, but considering how amazing the first book was, I think I just expected more.
A really good review, Mogsy:). But yes… that ending is a major disappointment! I think Harris is too experienced to fall prey to ‘second book fright’ – I get the feeling that for some reason publishing deadlines were looming and she was rushed into settling for a quick fix.
Yeah, it did seem like the ending was rushed. Or like she couldn’t figure out a better way to tie everything up, so the attitude was like, “whatever”. It’s a shame, really.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes! I absolutely agree:))
Pingback: Bookshelf Roundup 02/15/20: Stacking the Shelves & Recent Reads | The BiblioSanctum
I’ve definitely seen similar reviews, that’s disappointing! I have this out from the library and hope to get to it soon, maybe I’ll still like it though. *crossing my fingers*