Book Review: The Hollow Tree by James Brogden

I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.

The Hollow Tree by James Brogden

Mogsy’s Rating: 3.5 of 5 stars

Genre: Horror, Paranormal

Series: Stand Alone

Publisher: Titan Books (March 6, 2018)

Length: 483 pages

Author Information: Website | Twitter

I love horror novels based on urban legends, though in the case of The Hollow Tree, I only found out that it was inspired by a local myth in the author’s hometown after I finished the book. In his afterword, James Brogden describes the real life 1944 discovery of a woman’s skeleton inside the trunk of a hollow elm in Hagley Wood, Worchestershire, England. Her real identity was never discovered—and neither were her murderer’s—before the remains mysteriously went missing, and subsequently, a graffiti message appearing on a nearby wall reading “Who put Bella in the Wych Elm” soon solidified the legend behind the investigation. Fascinated, I went to do some more reading on the topic, and was chilled by what I found out. Unsolved crimes and mysteries tend to have that effect on me, and when it comes to the details behind “Wych Elm Bella”, I could certainly understand why the case would be a treasure trove of ideas for a horror writer.

Brogden, however, has created something truly vast and impressive out of Bella in the Wych Elm urban legend, drawing heavily on its basis as well as a lot of the rumors and theories surrounding it. The protagonist of The Hollow Tree is Rachel Cooper, a young woman whose life is suddenly shattered when she loses her hand in a traumatic boating accident. Fighting hard to remain optimistic through her recovery and therapy, she soon learns to adapt with living with only one hand, as well as how to deal with the symptoms related to limb loss such as phantom pain. But unfortunately, there is little she can do about the nightmares. In her dreams, she keeps seeing vivid images of a hollow tree, with a hand reaching out to her from it, as if begging for help. Soon, the visions get so bad that Rachel is starting to experience delusions even during her waking hours. Her missing hand also keeps bothering her, feeling so present and alive, experiencing all kinds of sensations that should not be possible. In a way, it almost feels like the hand is still there, but in another world…

For the purposes of this novel, the “Bella in the Wych Elm” legend has been changed to “Mary in the Hollow Oak”, though a lot of its other story elements have remained the same. I don’t really want to elaborate on how Rachel’s role relates to Mary’s fate in case I accidentally reveal too much, but suffice to say, the two women’s lives will be forever entwined because of Rachel’s connection to that “other place”.

To me, The Hollow Tree feels very much like a story told in several distinct parts. The first third of the book is a very good character study of Rachel. We’re along for the ride when she and her husband Tom go on that fateful boating trip that turns both their lives upside down, and the accident is as terrible as you would expect. I really felt for Rachel, who now must face her new reality of living without her left hand, but her determination and courageous attitude soon endeared me to her. I admired her a lot for her optimism, but at the same time, her struggles were portrayed realistically. Sometimes, memories of the incident would drag Rachel into a dark place, but those are also the moments in which her character felt the most genuine, with her true nature shining through as she resolutely refuses to wallow in her self-pity or to blame anyone for her problems. In fact, much of the suspense in this book stems from the fact that Rachel is so independent, always opting to tackle conflicts head on by herself, and that defiant streak often leaves her alone in many frightening situations.

For the rest of the book, however, my feelings were a bit more mixed. Sometimes, when too much is revealed too early on or all at once, a story can lose much of its mystique, and I think this is what happened here. Rachel’s nightmares and visions kept me intrigued for much of the first third; the ambiguity made me wonder if there was truly a supernatural explanation for all of the things she was seeing and dreaming, or perhaps they were simply the delusions of the protagonist’s stressed mind. So when all was revealed in the second third, it almost felt like the suspense was shattered too soon. In a way, it was like being able to see behind a magician’s tricks, removing all sense of wonder and mystery. While there was still plenty of action and danger to follow, sadly the story never quite managed to regain its foreboding atmosphere and eeriness, becoming a lot more like a straightforward paranormal thriller. Since I had been expecting a lot more horror, this made me feel slightly disappointed.

As a result, the later parts of the book took me a lot longer to read, because I just didn’t feel as invested in those sections of the story as I did in the first third. However, I won’t deny I found the ideas behind the novel intriguing, and I still loved the fact that it was inspired by a such a fascinating urban legend. While it’s true that the book could have been a lot more atmospheric and disturbing, ultimately I think The Hollow Tree would make a pretty good choice for fans of paranormal suspense and light horror.

More on The BiblioSanctum:
Guest Post: “The Cat-Mummy of Curzon Street Station” by James Brogden

26 Comments on “Book Review: The Hollow Tree by James Brogden”

  1. What a strange unsolved mystery. I must go and read up about it too. This sounds like a good book so it’s a shame that the mystery was revealed too soon.
    Lynn 😀


    • It just felt like a story told in multiple parts. The first part was definitely my favorite – it had more of a horror atmosphere, whereas the later parts read more like a paranormal thriller once the other world was “explained”.


  2. This book might not be the right one for me – the breaking of suspense and mystery at such an early stage sounds like a bad narrative choice, indeed – but I’m now very curious about the real life mystery/legend that stands at the core of the story, so I’m going to go and learn more… 🙂


    • I think you and I have similar tastes in horror. I’m definitely more about the suspense and atmosphere too. You’ll probably like the first half of the book, but as soon as the explanations are out in the open, the book switches to a straight-up thriller.


  3. I read his other book, Hekla’s Children and that was a wonderful mix of many things too. I’m quite intrigued by this because i like the way he writes, but also had the same issue with the other book, how the story suddenly changed direction and some of the mystery was lost and even the genre seemed different between parts of the book.


  4. Nice review! Yeah, a book revealing its hand too early on will definitely shatter the suspense, so I see how this book didn’t reach its full potential for you. Oh and yikes, the description of the premise already has me creeped out; I never dabble in horror, but the intrigue is kind of calling to me to pick it up… 😂


  5. I had originally planned on buying this one but I saw my local library got a copy. I’m really intrigued so I’ll just grab that one. That way if it doesn’t work for me, I don’t feel like I’ve wasted my hard-earned money.


  6. I’ve been so curious about this one! It’s probably not what I was hoping for. I’m fascinated by the real story, though. And how… did her remains go missing? Was she left in the tree after she was discovered? O_O


    • LOL, it really is quite bizarre isn’t it? I think I read somewhere that the police sent the remains to some universities or labs to get analyzed, but then lost track of them somewhere along the way. I guess they didn’t keep the best records back then, and of course the bones’ disappearance led to all sorts of conspiracies 😀


  7. Pingback: Mogsy’s Bookshelf Roundup: Stacking the Shelves & Recent Reads | The BiblioSanctum

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: