Book Review: Fellside by M.R. Carey

A review copy was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

FellsideFellside by M.R. Carey

Mogsy’s Rating: 4 of 5 stars

Genre: Horror, Mystery

Series: Stand Alone

Publisher: Orbit (April 5, 2016)

Length: 496 pages

Author Information: Website | Twitter

After the brilliant novel that was The Girl with All the Gifts, I swore to myself I would read anything else M.R. Carey writes. Not long after, I was practically beside myself when I found out he was going to be writing a ghost story.

Turns out, Fellside is a very different kind of ghostly tale, and not exactly in the horror vein. Instead, it’s a little bit of mystery, a little bit of paranormal, and even a little bit of court drama, all bundled up in a wonderful package along with Carey’s unique brand of imagination and creativity. The story follows Jess Moulson, a junkie convicted after she set fire to her apartment complex following a heroin bender, accidentally killing her neighbor’s ten-year-old son who was home alone. Even though Jess has no recollection of the events that went down that night, the court ruled it as murder and sentenced her to life in a maximum security prison called Fellside.

Jess is haunted the moment she arrives, not only by the ghost of Alex Beech, the boy she killed, but also by the shame, loneliness and guilt she feels from all the mistakes she made in the past. But instead of plummeting her further into darkness, the spirit of Alex actually rescues her from the abyss and gives her a new sense of hope. Jess immediately makes an enemy of a fellow prisoner named Harriet Grace, the boss of G-Block, when she refuses to run drugs for Grace’s corrupt racket. The road to redemption, Jess believes, is not to commit even more wrongdoings, even though she is aware such attitudes might eventually get her shanked in a place like Fellside. But she has a purpose now, and she is determined to see it through to the end even if it kills her.

In a book like this, there are not a lot of sympathetic characters. In fact, the beginning of Fellside made me boiling mad, and not just because of all the healthcare professionals, prison guards, and other authority figures who were corrupt and/or incompetent, but also because that seemed like such an easy way out for an author to paint someone as a villain. Even someone like Jess took time to grow on me, given the complete and utter disaster she was at the beginning of the story. After all, it is hard to sympathize with someone who has abandoned all hope, becoming entirely convinced of her own worthlessness. However, I now know that Carey set it up this way for a purpose; Jess had to fall far before he could raise her up again and juxtapose that to the new person she becomes. Even so, my favorite characters ultimately came from the most unexpected quarters, mostly minor bit players like Shannon McBride, Fellside’s resident storyteller, or Lorraine Buller, Jess’s taciturn yet compassionate cellmate.

The story also didn’t hook me right away, mostly because of its many moving parts that didn’t all come together until the second half of the novel. I didn’t care much for the humdrum chapters on Harriet Grace’s drug-running ring, for example, at least until that plot thread collided with Jess’s. Things became many times more interesting when the story morphed from a prison drama to a full-blown mystery. While I plodded through the first part of the book, I must have read the last two hundred pages or so in a single sitting, so energized as I was at the plot’s new direction. I definitely found the ending to be stronger than the beginning, even though it started running along a more predictable path. There was a court scene which was especially played up for dramatic effect, but hell, I ate it all up. I could hardly have made myself put down the book by that point.

Even if you enjoyed The Girl with All the Gifts, it’s difficult to say if you’ll enjoy Fellside, simply because the two books are so different. Fellside is not your typical ghost story, more suspenseful rather than creepy, and I can see it appealing more to mystery fans than horror buffs. Still, there are some mirroring themes. As ever, Carey is fond of keeping his readers in the dark right up until he springs the big surprises. And then there are scenes of intense violence, but when all is said and done, we’re also left with a spark of hope.

Finally, of course, there’s the author’s writing itself, which is as bold and hauntingly evocative as I expected. No disappointment there, as far as I’m concerned. If anything, this novel demonstrates Carey’s versatility and my admiration for his talent has actually increased. While it took me some time to warm up to Fellside, I ended up really enjoying the story’s poignant look at life on the inside of a women’s prison, as well as the memorable characters you’ll love to hate and hate to love. Recommended for fans of paranormal mysteries and suspense.


Mogsy 2

18 Comments on “Book Review: Fellside by M.R. Carey”

  1. When authors keep challenging themselves and try new roads, instead of following an old, tested ones, they show both courage and ability: I’m glad to know this new novel is radically different from the previous one, and even if it’s a “slow burn”, I’m certain it will be worth the effort. Thanks for a very insightful review: I was waiting for this one! 🙂


    • Yeah, if given the choice I think I would prefer to try something different than to have more of the same old same old. No matter what he writes though, I love the ideas that come out of Carey’s mind 🙂


  2. I was going to read this next but realised I had something else to fit in – sounds good though ‘the author’s writing itself, which is as bold and hauntingly evocative as I expected. No disappointment there, as far as I’m concerned. If anything, this novel demonstrates Carey’s versatility and my admiration for his talent has actually increased’ – and this is very promising!
    Lynn 😀


    • I am always having those moments too – last minute changes to my reading schedule of those “oops, gotta leap frog this book ahead of this one” moments 😉 I hope you’ll enjoy this once you get to it!


  3. This is my next book, and I’m pretty excited! I love when authors don’t write the same book twice, so I’m glad to hear this is quite different from TGWATG.


    • Yes, as I was saying I think I’d prefer something brand new than to read something that rehashes old ground. I would rather take my chances on something new, and I think Carey’s gambit paid off in spades!


  4. I find it hard to read books that are set in prisons. But I’m tempted to give this one a shot. I like the sound of this being a ghost story that isn’t horror and that the character has to set herself on a new path in life.


  5. Ugh… it might be a good book, but that cover REALLY bothers me. The yellow “Girl with all the Gifts” circles, looks like it’s a sticker that someplace on it at a store to help sell it. I want to scratch it off so bad! And why would they do that (with the picture of the cover) when it isn’t even a sequel? Couldn’t they just put: author of the….? Bad marketing decision, in my opinion.


    • I agree, I honestly can’t imagine why they would put these books out to print with that big yellow TGwAtG circle on the cover. I thought that maybe only the earliest images would have that for reasons for promotion, but apparently they’re all the cover images are like this. It’s so distracting!


  6. Pingback: Mogsy’s Bookshelf Roundup: Stacking the Shelves & Recent Reads | The BiblioSanctum

  7. Pingback: All The Science Fiction And Fantasy Books You Can't Afford To Miss In April | Gizmodo Australia

  8. Pingback: All The Science Fiction And Fantasy Books You Can’t Afford To Miss In April – Get Your Geek Fix

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: