#RRSciFiMonth Mini Reviews: Journey to Star Wars The Force Awakens

Sci-Fi MonthSci-Fi November is a month-long blog event hosted by Rinn Reads and Over The Effing Rainbow this year, created to celebrate everything amazing about science fiction! From TV shows to movies, books to comics, and everything else in between, it is intended to help science fiction lovers share their love and passion for this genre and its many, many fandoms.

Lost StarsLost Stars by Claudia Gray

Genre: Young Adult, Science Fiction

Series: Journey to Star Wars: The Force Awakens

Publisher: Disney/LucasFilm Press (9/4/15)

Author Information: Website | Twitter

Mogsy’s Rating: 4.5 of 5 stars

And to think, I almost gave this one a pass when I was compiling a list of books I wanted to read from the new Star Wars canon. What a mistake that would have been. Yes, this is categorized as Young Adult, but to be sure, this is not the kind of Star Wars YA from the old EU when the stories tended to lean more towards middle-grade audiences and few children’s series stood out strongly enough to make an impression. Lost Stars, in a word, was awesome. I have been reading Star Was novels for years and have read many of them during that time, but this has got to be one of the best I’ve ever read.

The book tells the tale of two childhood friends who became lovers before ending up on opposite sides of the galactic war. Ciena and Thane grew up on the same planet just after annexation by the Imperials, but one was born in the more rural valley while the other came from an affluent second-waver family. However, the two met and bonded over a shared love for piloting and a dream to one day fly for the Empire. They entered the Imperial academy together, excited to be with each other as they made that dream come true. But as the war waged on, their fates diverged as one grew disillusioned with the Empire and joined the Rebel Alliance, while the other remained in Imperial service and rose through its ranks to become a high-ranking officer.

The beauty of this book is in its simplicity. At the heart of it is a love story, so you might not enjoy it as much if YA Romance isn’t your cup of tea. At the same time though, it is surprisingly free of the tropes that usually clog up this genre, and I didn’t feel as if the plot was made more complicated by any needless drama. Instead, all the good stuff comes through, themes like: honor versus duty, love and grief, opportunities lost and things left unsaid. Ciena and Thane are the loves of each other’s lives, but they were raised in very different homes, with very different values. Because of that, there will always be a part in each of them that can and never will be reconciled.

And you know what else is great? How deeply and intimately Lost Stars is tied to the original trilogy. You get to relive the major events of each movie from a whole different perspective. No doubt about it, while reading this book I felt like I was 100% in the Star Wars universe. And yet, the story also retains its own uniqueness. You ever think to yourself, surely, the Empire can’t be one homogenous body working in unison towards the same goal? Of course there had to be different factions, as well as good people in the Imperial forces who couldn’t stand by and do nothing while their side committed all sorts of atrocities. This book does a really good job showing this, and in a way it humanizes the Empire by portraying the protagonists as average everyday people.

Like anyone, both Ciena and Thane have close family and friends. They each have their own personal hopes and dreams. They experience desire and longing. My heart ached for the two of them and I wanted so badly for things to work out for them in the end. Move over Anakin and Padme and Episode II, because this is romance done right. Heck, this is “Journey to Star Wars: The Force Awakens” done right.

“Look through my eyes…look through my eyes.” *Happy sigh*

05ad9-4-5stars

* * *

AftermathAftermath by Chuck Wendig

Genre: Science Fiction

Series: Journey to Star Wars: The Force Awakens

Publisher: Del Rey (9/4/15)

Author Information: Website | Twitter

Mogsy’s Rating: 3 of 5 stars

This was it, the long-awaited novel in the new Star Wars canon that was marketed as the “bridge” between Return of the Jedi and the new upcoming movie. In retrospect, the publisher might have oversold that just a tad. Well, okay, maybe a lot more than just a tad. Call me cynical though, but I never really expected to see this book provide much detail. In truth, I was more excited to see one of my favorite authors tackle one of my favorite franchises.

I did have my misgivings though. Chuck Wendig’s Blackbirds in my eyes is one of the best books ever. But it is also as far away from a general-audience thing like Star Wars as you can get.  I love Wendig’s style for its gritty dark edginess and his brand of dry, sarcastic wit, and I worried that writing for a media tie-in would come with a lot of restrictions, leading him to dial it way back. In the end, I think something like this must have happened, because while I typically adore Wendig’s writing, I somehow found myself struggling with it in Aftermath. Something vital felt missing, which made his normally punchy and enjoyable style feel awkward, choppy, and grating here instead. I even had to switch to the audiobook version midway, which fortunately made getting through the book easier. Wendig is a fantastic writer, but I feel his style is  more suited to urban fantasy, and feels a little out of place in the Star Wars universe, especially given his tendency to use many modern colloquialisms in his prose that jolted me out of the story.

And speaking of story, it was decent but not great. The problem was the lack of any compelling characters. Being a fan of expanded universes and tie-ins of all media, not just Star Wars, I have no problems with making the acquaintances of new faces, but in Aftermath there were JUST. SO. MANY.  It was impossible to form an attachment to any one character, not even the familiar ones like good old Wedge Antilles or Rae Sloane the Imperial Admiral who was first introduced in A New Dawn. And so like many of the middling Star Wars novels I have read, I had a good enough time enjoying this ride, but never truly felt invested in the fate of the characters or the plot direction.

Furthermore, as I’d alluded to before, this isn’t exactly the “aftermath” I was expecting. It barely has anything to do with the destruction of the Death Star at end of ROTJ, nor does it give us many clues for The Force Awakens. It reads like any other new adventure with new characters; the story doesn’t feel whole, it feels a lot more like an introduction. It’s fun, but it’s fluffy. It lacks weight.

Aside from feeling sad about the loss of a couple great stories, for the most part I’m actually quite happy about the new canon. There was so much bloat in the old EU and I cringe whenever I think about how many years of my life I wasted torturing myself trying to finish series that aren’t even all that great (*cough* New Jedi Order *cough*). Good riddance, I say. I’m actually really optimistic about the wonderful possibilities going forward. So far, the majority of the new books have impressed me. Aftermath was actually a pretty decent read too, and my 3-star rating reflects that. Still, for a book I anticipated so much, it’s hard not to see that as a disappointment. For the first post-ROTJ novel, I admit I’d hoped for something more.

758dc-new3stars

Advertisements

23 Comments on “#RRSciFiMonth Mini Reviews: Journey to Star Wars The Force Awakens

    • Honestly, I think that whole controversy got blown out of proportion by a very small minority of idiots and a good number of trolls who relished in causing even more drama. I wish I could blame it all on that and say Aftermath is in fact totally awesome, but unfortunately I have to say the majority of bad reviews bring up legit points about the weaknesses and issues. I was unimpressed by the characters and the storytelling was choppy. Definitely not a 1 or 2 star read, but not great either – just okay, but it was entertaining!

      Like

  1. One of the best Star Wars book? I haven’t read any of new canon, yet, but when I do, I’ll probably check that one out them.

    I enjoy tie in fiction too, but when the book relates more to the movie (or game or whatever) it adds a little extra something more than a random story in the same universe.

    Speaking of older canon, i still want to read the X-Wing series so bad! I’ll probably stick to reading the new Star Wars books – because they are canon – but I’ll make an exception for that series and Red Harvest.

    Like

    • I still need to read the X-Wing series too! It’s so hard to motivate myself to read the Legends stuff now though, especially since so many of the books just…weren’t great. I’ve dropped several series just because I couldn’t deal with the the blah anymore. I do still need to read Red Harvest as well, but I’ve read Death Troopers and yeah, it was pretty awesome 🙂

      Like

  2. Great reviews, I agree with you on Lost Stars. A well done book, and arguably the end is a pretty good lead in to the new movie- seeing a certain big ship in the sand will be different after reading this one. 🙂 I like your point too about how part of them couldn’t be reconciled- I thought that was realistic.

    As for aftermath, haven’t read it but heard it was less than stellar. I think it would irritate me a bit if I read it and there was no real clues to the new movie, since that angle has been pushed a bit. Oh well.

    Like

    • Yes I agree, Lost Stars had more of the “aftermath” I’d wanted to see 🙂 I wish it had gotten more attention at release, but ever since Force Friday all everyone seems to talk about is Aftermath – which didn’t turn out to be that great a book! I was kinda let down, true…though I’d still give it a shot if you’re interested in completion, and the story had its moments (Mr. Bones!) 🙂

      Like

  3. I had already added Lost Stars based on an intriguing twitter mention, now I am super duper excited about it! I am actually a big fan of the time worn tropes – like star-crossed lovers – but they have to be written well and it sounds like this hits it out of the park.

    Like

  4. Thanks for this. I have Aftermath in my Audible library. I also have the Thawn Trilogy – I do love Marc Thompson’s narration and the inclusion of the movie music and sound effects. So, would you suggest I finish the Thawn trilogy (only listened to book one so far) start Aftermath or pick up Lost Stars?

    I love the movies and am looking for something to whet my appetite even more for Force Awakens (not that it needs much whetting…)

    Like

  5. Pingback: Mogsy’s Bookshelf Roundup: Stacking the Shelves, NaNoWriMo, Recent Reads | The BiblioSanctum

  6. Pingback: #RRSciFiMonth: Mogsy’s Top 10 Sci-Fi Reads of 2015 | The BiblioSanctum

  7. Pingback: Mogsy: Best of 2015 and the Year in Review | The BiblioSanctum

  8. Pingback: Book Review: Star Wars: Aftermath: Life Debt by Chuck Wendig | The BiblioSanctum

  9. Pingback: Audiobook Review: Star Wars: Aftermath: Empire’s End by Chuck Wendig | The BiblioSanctum

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: