#RRSciFiMonth: Planetfall by Emma Newman

Sci-Fi Month

Sci-Fi November is a month-long blog event hosted by Rinn Reads and Over The Effing Rainbow this year, created to celebrate everything amazing about science fiction! From TV shows to movies, books to comics, and everything else in between, it is intended to help science fiction lovers share their love and passion for this genre and its many, many fandoms.

A review copy was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

PlanetfallPlanetfall by Emma Newman

Genre: Science Fiction

Series: Stand Along

Publisher: Roc (11/3/15)

Author Information: Website | Twitter

Mogsy’s Rating: 3.5 of 5 stars

Long story short: I loved Planetfall…except the ending. If you’ve ever enjoyed a great book that you nonetheless had serious issues with, then you’d probably know what I’m feeling. I’m still fantastically happy I read it though, because it has an amazing premise; while it does take a while for events to unfold, following along as they do was half the fun.

The story opens on a world far from Earth. Protagonist Renata Ghali is called urgently to the colony boundary when a mysterious figure is spotted heading towards the settlement. As the stranger approaches, even though Ren doesn’t recognize him, she sees that he bears a striking resemblance to her friend Suh-Mi, also known as the Pathfinder—the woman who had led their group here to this planet all those years ago to escape a polluted and over-populated Earth. But then, more than two decades have passed since they arrived here on a mission of faith and Suh-Mi had entered the gargantuan alien structure they found when they made planetfall. They called it God’s City, and everyone knows the Pathfinder is within it now, convening with a higher power in order to impart her wisdom to the colonists.

So, just who is this mysterious newcomer? He came alone, and it is astounding to think he’s survived by himself after all this time out there in the hostile alien wilderness. He’s also too young to be part of their original group to arrive on the ship to this planet. The young man claims to be the grandson of Suh-Mi, but only Ren and the colony master Cillian “Mack” Mackenzie know why that information would be dangerous. If it’s true, it could mean an end to the colony’s whole way of life, a life that they have spent years attempting to cultivate into their own little utopia.

First off, I love colonization sci-fi. I love that theme of arriving at a whole new world, establishing a territory and building a new home with your blood, sweat, and tears. I find these kinds of stories fascinating, celebrating the pioneer spirit at all levels, and sometimes the personal narratives of the characters can be very inspirational. Planetfall, on the other hand, has a darker tone, and it’s a very different and unique offering in this subgenre. I was compelled by the mysterious vibe, the way the plot slowly revealed itself in layers, often in the form of flashbacks and memories. Bit by bit, you can piece together a better picture of what’s really going on.

One issue, however, was my feelings for the protagonist. That’s the funny thing about me and characters; sometimes I can relate to them even when they’re wholly unlikeable. Their personalities can be abrasive, repulsive, or completely at odds with mine, but if they’re written well, most of the time I manage to make a connection anyway. Unfortunately, this was just not the case with Renata. When it came to Ren, I always felt like there was a gap there I couldn’t bridge. It’s not that she’s unlikeable, because she has some very sympathetic qualities. Yet I still had a hard time feeling anything for her but pity, and I hated that. Part of the reason is the way she was written, and the fact that the story places a rather large focus on her mental disorder. I think it’s important to explore these issues, but in Ren’s case, her compulsive behavior is used as a convenient plot device. I could feel the author’s hand very strongly in the story thread surrounding Ren’s struggles, and it only emphasized how unempowered the character was. It’s possible that I’m being oversensitive about this, but in any case, I wasn’t entirely comfortable with it.

My main issue though, was the ending. As I approached the final 10% of the novel, I started to feel a little nervous. Knowing beforehand that this was a standalone and that there had to be so much more left in the story to be addressed, I did wonder how the author was going to wrap everything up with so few pages left. The result was unexpected, to say the least. It felt like someone flipped a switch on this story and scrambled all its circuits. It was hard to believe I was still reading the same book. It’s difficult to describe, but everything following the climax felt like a string of non sequiturs, the tone and style and narrative veering off in a drastically unpredictable direction. Sometimes “curveballs” in a story are good, but I’m still torn about this one.

Still, Planetfall is a book I would recommend. In its finer moments the book is a thought-provoking narrative about the fear of the unknown, and how in times of uncertainty, those around you can be a comfort…or a strain. I love Emma Newman’s writing style, which gracefully highlights some of the darkness and heartbreak in the story. Slight feelings of frustration and disappointment are still lingering from that random ending and the lack of answers, but overall this was a good read.


18 Comments on “#RRSciFiMonth: Planetfall by Emma Newman”

  1. You’ve got me so curious now! I just started reading this, so I can’t say at this point how I’ll feel about it, but it’s such a foreign world and feels pretty original, at least in the beginning stages. EVERYONE has been raving about this, so I can’t wait to see where I fall when it’s over:-)


  2. Yay for sci-fi month starting 😀 And, oooh, colonization sci-fi is the best, love it when the characters explore the terrain for the first time and have to figure out how to survive. Also, too bad that the ending kind of left a bad reading aftertaste. Sometimes if I really don’t like an ending to a book, I just…pretend it never happened, ha. Although, I have hated ending of books before but waited a few months…and years even, and then got around to finally liking it!


    • Yeah, I think I like colonization sci-fi for the same reasons I love fantasy western settings! I love the settler spirit and the idea of exploring wild frontiers 🙂


  3. I’m very curious about this. It sounds very interesting, but I’m concerned based off your issues with the ending. I’ve read a few recently where parts are a five and parts are a two. It’s disappointed me even though I love the parts that are a five. I may need to put this on the TBR for a later date. Great review.


    • I’d be very interested to hear your thoughts, if you read this. Looking around, it seems I’m in the minority of not liking the ending, so it might just be me 🙂


  4. When it comes to reading, I’m a believer of “it’s the journey that matters”, however, sometimes a bad ending can really ruin a story.

    I’d still give this one a read though. The colonization aspects of the story is interesting, and doesn’t this have some 3D printer in it too?


    • Oh yes, there’s tons of 3D printing! Their whole society relies on it, actually. If you want to read a book where 3D printing is a huge component, then you’d be in heaven 😀


  5. Pingback: Mogsy’s Bookshelf Roundup: Stacking the Shelves, NaNoWriMo, Recent Reads | The BiblioSanctum

  6. Pingback: Book Review: Before Mars by Emma Newman | The BiblioSanctum

  7. Pingback: Book Review: Atlas Alone by Emma Newman | The BiblioSanctum

  8. Pingback: #SciFiMonth Sci-5 Tuesday: Colonization Sci-Fi | The BiblioSanctum

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: