Book Review: When the Heavens Fall by Marc Turner

A review copy of this book was provided to me by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

When The Heavens FallWhen the Heavens Fall by Marc Turner

Genre: Fantasy

Series: Book 1 of  The Chronicles of the Exile

Publisher: Tor (May 19, 2015)

Author Information: Website | Twitter

Mogsy’s Rating: 3 of 5 stars

Marc Turner’s When the Heavens Fall was a book that snuck quietly onto my radar earlier this year. I knew next to nothing about it beyond the official publisher’s description, and so as with most things shrouded in mystery, I was instantly intrigued and hoping it would score a surprise hit. In retrospect, my first impressions might have been different if I had kept my expectations more in line, but even after they were tempered I knew I probably wouldn’t be shelving this one under my favorites. That’s not to say it’s a bad book, because this is a very solid debut. However, some parts just didn’t work for me as well as it probably would for other readers.

At first glance, this seemed like your classic quest narrative. All the characters and events appeared to be linked to the theft of an extremely powerful and dangerous magical artifact called the Book of Lost Souls. Hidden long ago by the death god Shroud, a rogue mage called Mayot Mencada has since uncovered the tome and spirited it away deep into the Forest of Sighs. This sparks the beginning of the story for four different characters, each with their own agendas. Luker is a former Guardian who embarks on this journey to search not for the book but for his mentor, who was the last person to go after Mayot. Tasked to keep an eye on things is a priestess named Romany, whose patron goddess the Spider was the one who manipulated Mayot into stealing the book in the first place. Then there’s Ebon, heir to a kingdom on the edge of the Forest of Sighs, who is also plagued by voices of spirits in his head. And finally, there’s Parolla, a young woman who seeks entry into Shroud’s realm to settle an old debt with the Lord of the Dead himself.

I think most epic fantasies I’ve read are structured in a way so that each chapter is given to a different character perspective in order to keep all the points-of-view straight. However, When the Heavens Fall does not follow this format, instead switching from viewpoint to viewpoint randomly within chapters, which is one reason why the first 100 pages gave me so much trouble. This constant jumping around – especially when the story is dealing with multiple characters in different locations – gives the introduction a sense of disorganization. This section also holds a lot of background information, and the fact that it’s so densely packed slows down the pacing quite a bit.

To its credit, the book picks up by a lot after the first half. It’s not a coincidence that this is also when the four different storylines begin to converge and when I finally started to spot the connections. Each plot thread does have its ups and downs, though. For example, Luker’s story didn’t capture my interest until the finale, since so much of his story about search for the book/his mentor felt like wheels spinning in place. after losing much of its traction past the first few chapters. On the other hand, Parolla’s story was just the opposite; so much about her was an unknown in the intro, but the more I learned about her and her quest, the more excited I became about her character. And because Romany so often dealt in the metaphysical realm and appeared in a spiritual form, that abstraction might have predisposed me against her chapters. Perhaps the only one whose story I consistently enjoyed was Ebon’s, with his struggles to protect his kingdom in the face of undead attackers and dubious allies. When the four characters find themselves all together in the final showdown against Mayot though, that’s when things get real. This is a very large and intricate web that Marc Turner has spun, and while it does take a little patience, I promise everything will eventually click into place. The ending is truly superb.

I see in Marc Turner’s profile that he names Steven Erikson and Joe Abercrombie as his major influences. After reading When the Heavens Fall, I can definitely see that, though I would say his writing style leans more towards the former author than the latter. Certainly I feel it is closer to Erikson than Patrick Rothfuss, who is the one mentioned in the book’s blurb. I’ve seen several reviewers compare this one to the Malazan books, and in fact I agree they are quite similar in style and tone with that dark, epic feel. Magic is a very complex and abstract concept here, and in a novel like this which is not immune to its fair share of common fantasy tropes, I have to say the system of necromancy and dark sorcery is its most unique and striking aspect.

All in all, this was a good book, though I won’t deny there were many parts that presented a real struggle. The biggest obstacle was the pacing, which was uneven in parts and slowed the momentum. Furthermore, it’s possible my enjoyment was impeded by the fact this might not even be the type of epic fantasy I would normally go for. It’s interesting to note I couldn’t get into Erikson’s Malazan either, so the problem likely isn’t with the book, it’s with me. What this means is I can see When the Heavens Fall working extremely well for some readers, but I just wasn’t swept off my feet. For you, this could end up one of your favorite reads this year. For me, it was an experience I wish I could have enjoyed more. Still, I don’t regret reading this. It was a new and refreshing encounter with a very different kind of sword and sorcery.

679d6-new3stars

16 Comments on “Book Review: When the Heavens Fall by Marc Turner”

  1. Ah yes I saw the book a fw times and I was wondering if I should take it or not and now with your review I understand that maybe it’s not really for me in fact. Thanks for your help!

    Like

  2. That is funny. I actually thought Ebon’s early chapters were the weakest among the beginning. I was rolling my eyes at the ‘negotiations’ he was going through.

    Like

    • I find it really interesting reading the different reviews of this and seeing which characters’ stories appealed to the readers the most. Pretty awesome how everyone had their personal favorite and least favorite, and they vary so wildly and for so many different reasons.

      Like

  3. A fair review. I think you picked up on a lot of the things that nagged at me a bit too. It was fun, and I enjoyed it, but it won’t be going on any end of the year best-of lists. I didn’t call it out, but I can definitely see the Malazan influence, although Turner never achieves that level of depth and complexity.

    Like

    • I wish I had been able to get into Malazan, but after the first book I knew it probably wasn’t for me. Maybe I’ll give it another try someday, I’m sure the books are so widely beloved for a reason, which is another reason why I think it’s not this book, it’s just me.

      Like

  4. This one just didn’t catch my eye, and it’s probably for the best after reading your review, although I have read some 4 star reviews here and there.

    Like

  5. Wow. Rothfuss is so far from Erikson, I’m baffled how an author could be compared to both 🙂 Sorry to hear about the pacing issues though. Always unfortunate when a book loses its reader because of that. I plan on finishing this eventually 🙂

    Like

  6. Pingback: Mogsy’s Bookshelf Roundup: New Books, Backlist, What I’ve Been Reading | The BiblioSanctum

  7. I must say that I didn’t get the Rothfuss similarities with this at all. I’ve only read an excerpt at the moment so still want to complete and see how it spins out – at the moment I’ve given it a 3.5 to give it room to grow – or not! We’ll see.
    Lynn 😀

    Like

  8. You know what? I couldn’t get into the Malazan saga either. I did read the first book, but I struggled with it all through the second part. Never picked up any of the others.
    So I suppose this is not the book for me either. Shame, though, I love that cover 🙂

    Like

  9. Pingback: Book Review: Dragon Hunters by Marc Turner | The BiblioSanctum

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: