Book Review: Diavola by Jennifer Thorne
Posted on May 5, 2024 23 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
Mogsy’s Rating: 4 of 5 stars
Genre: Horror
Series: Stand Alone
Publisher: Nightfire (March 26, 2024)
Length: 293 pages
Author Information: Website
Diavola by Jennifer Thorne is the second haunted house book set in Italy that I’ve read in as many months (the other being The House of Last Resort by Christopher Golden). In a way, that’s not too surprising; Italy boasts a long and rich history filled with a wealth of folklore and superstition—the perfect backdrop for the eerie and unexplained. The concept of ghosts and spirits is prevalent, as well as strong beliefs in the supernatural. But what’s great about this particular novel is the blending of gothic folk horror with the hilarity and torment of a dysfunctional family vacation, a recipe promising more than just a ghost story.
For many, the idea of spending a few sun-soaked summer days in a luxurious villa in Tuscany would sound like a dream holiday, but for Anna Pace, it is a nightmare. That’s because she’ll be traveling with her family, who will never let her forget all the ways she has been a disappointment or a failure. Still, black sheep or not, as the only member who can speak fluent Italian, she’s roped in for the ride and stuck with interpreter duty. And sure enough, the vacation has barely begun and her parents are already tight-lipped with their simmering disapproval, her older sister Nicole with her seemingly perfect family can’t stop making snide and passive aggressive comments, and her twin brother Benny has brought along his pretentious boyfriend who doesn’t even try to hide his dislike for Anna.
But the real chills begin when the Paces arrive at the quaint little property that they’ve rented in the remote village of Monteperso. It was supposed to be their quiet refuge away from the more bustling touristy areas, a place to relax and unwind each night after packed days of beach visits and sightseeing trips. However, the villa turns out to be anything but peaceful. Doors and drawers open and shut on their own. Strange, disembodied whispers can be heard at night. Anna starts having disturbing dreams and visions. When her family goes out in town, the locals seem afraid and clam up around them when they mention where they are staying. Anna has the sense that something is seriously wrong, but as always, any attempts to warn her family are waved off with derision and contempt.
I first discovered the author with her book Lute and having enjoyed that one very much, I looked forward to Diavola and its mix of spine-tingling horror and family drama. Once again, Thorne manages to deliver a tale thick with atmospheric dread, the prose and its vivid descriptions bringing the sights and sounds of the ancient Tuscan villa. Somehow, this backdrop perfectly complements the simmering tensions within the Pace family with their long history of bitter resentment and hostility.
We get to experience many of these toxic relationships through Anna’s eyes, but while her family members may treat her appallingly, there’s a touch of the unreliable narrator in our protagonist too as we realize her memories and perceptions might be colored by her own frustrated feelings of being the outsider. The story delves deeply into these complex dynamics, and I’m sure anyone who has ever vacationed with extended family can relate. The Paces, however, are on a whole other level. From baseless accusations to passive aggressive jabs, their dysfunction transcends the usual family squabbles, turning this Italian vacation into a pressure cooker ready to explode.
In fact, their desperation to salvage the situation must have been strong, because I think most sane people would have cut their losses and got the hell out of there soon after the first terrifying experience—and things certainly do get creepy! The setting is ideal for a haunted house story, the villa with its creaky corridors and mysteriously locked spaces. There’s even an eeriness to the quiet beauty of the surrounding village, steeped in local legends and home to superstitious folk. These spooky vibes add another layer of anxiety (and entertainment) to make the horror all the more immersive and keep you on your toes.
![]()
![]()
Audiobook Review: The Gathering by C.J. Tudor
Posted on April 29, 2024 19 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
Mogsy’s Rating: 4.5 of 5 stars
Genre: Horror, Mystery, Thriller
Series: Stand Alone
Publisher: Random House Audio (April 9, 2024)
Length: 10 hrs and 22 mins
Author Information: Website
Narrator: Lorelei King
C.J. Tudor and vampires? Surprising, but perhaps not unexpected. I’ve read and enjoyed all the author’s books to varying degrees, and it just seemed like a natural progression for her to take a familiar monster and reinvent it with a special twist.
The Gathering unfolds in Deadhart, a small Alaskan town where the discovery of a murdered teenager’s body drained of blood reignites the townspeople’s fear. Residents are already on edge with the establishment of a nearby Colony, a protected community of vampyrs settled into the old mine settlement, and they suspect that one of their members is the culprit. But led by the child vampyr Athelinda, who is in actuality hundreds of years old, the Colony vehemently denies any involvement.
Enter Detective Barbara Atkins, a vampyr specialist assigned to investigate the brutal killing. However, her arrival is met with a mix of apprehension and hostility. Some of the townsfolk believe her to be the answer to their problems, while others mistrust her intentions and fear that she may be vampyr sympathizer in cahoots with the creatures themselves. Unfazed, Barbara is determined to uncover the truth, partnering up with Jenson Tucker, Deadhart’s former sheriff who handled a similar murder decades ago. As the two of them delve deeper into the mystery, the case takes an ominous turn as bitter histories and hidden agendas are revealed.
Of all of Tudor’s novels, The Gathering reads the most like a police procedural whodunit, though the story also stretches beyond the boundaries of the genre. It begins with the characters themselves. Barbara is a refreshing protagonist, a lady detective who describes herself as middle-aged and overweight. Despite a childhood growing up in an abusive home and her own traumatic memories involving a vampyr in a Colony town, she’s come to Deadhart with an objective mind and commitment to truth over emotion, a clear head over mob mentality. Her team-up with Tucker adds another layer of intrigue, as the stoic ex-lawman is also haunted by his own demons.
As well, I love, love, LOVE settings like Deadhart, Alaska. This old mining town isn’t just a backdrop, it’s part of the whole novel’s vibe itself. The isolation and perpetual darkness turn the beauty of this snowy wilderness into a chilling prison for the town’s residents, pinned down by geography and weather, resulting in a chilling atmosphere that perfectly complements the story’s suspense. As desperation mounts, the tension builds like the pressure in a boiling kettle, and in this turmoil, Tudor throws a whole new rulebook at vampiric lore. In this world, Colony vampyrs are integrated, albeit uncomfortably, into human society. Despite being protected by law, they face prejudice and suspicion, a reflection of some of the issues faced by the real world, and are still vulnerable to “culls”, a sanctioned massacre of a Colony if a licensed authority like Barbara determines one to be a threat.
From start to finish, The Gathering also kept me engaged with its fast-paced plot made up of layers of secrets just waiting to be peeled back. Barbara and Tucker’s investigation takes unexpected turns, forcing her to confront not only the animosity of the town’s residents, who all seem to have something to hide, but the shady motives of Athelinda and her Colony vampyrs as well. I also have a thing for detective plotlines, and the numerous false leads and unexpected twists in this complex tale made it even more exciting to read.
All in all, C.J. Tudor once more weaves a web of horror and mystery in The Gathering, but I think it’s the police procedural aspect that I enjoyed the most and why I think it may be my favorite of her books yet. It was also a treat to listen to the audiobook, read by one of my favorite narrators. Lorelei King, who I love from her work on the Mercy Thompson series, is next-level amazing, and I believe a reader of her caliber needs no further comment.
![]()
![]()
Book Review: The Last Phi Hunter by Salinee Goldenberg
Posted on April 25, 2024 20 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
The Last Phi Hunter by Salinee Goldenberg
Mogsy’s Rating: 4.5 of 5 stars
Genre: Fantasy
Series: Stand Alone
Publisher: Angry Robot (April 9, 2024)
Length: 384 pages
Author Information: Website
Everyone, I present to you the hidden gem of the year! I had absolute blast with The Last Phi Hunter by Salinee Goldenberg, which took me by surprise in the best possible way, throwing open the doors to a fantasy world unlike any other.
The book opens with our protagonist stalking his prey. Ex is the youngest member of an order of demon slayers protecting the Suyoram Kingdom from the ghosts and monstrous spirits known as Phi, and he’s about to fulfill another contract. But as usual, the rural village that hired him ends up being unable to pay in full, leaving Ex in a bit of a jam. His path takes an unexpected turn, however, when he encounters Arinya, a pregnant warrior heading into the demon-infested forest search of its resident witch. Since Ex is going the same way, he agrees to escort her.
As it turns out, Arinya was looking for someone to perform a spell that would safeguard the soul of her unborn baby. In the process, Ex discovers the truth behind Arinya’s identity and why she needed the protection ritual, leading to his vow to keep her safe. As the two of them venture deeper into the treacherous wilderness, Ex’s feelings for his traveling companion begin to deepen, throwing his entire mission into disarray. His hunt for a legendary demon remains his ultimate goal, but his burgeoning affection for Arinya is also forcing him to confront his own vulnerabilities.
This is a story that takes readers on a whirlwind adventure that’s both thrilling and entertaining. The Last Phi Hunter grabbed my attention right away with its breezy prose and witty tones. It also excels in its pacing, unfolding quickly and organically while revealing details about the world, its magic, and its Phis without missing a beat. Even though it’s a lot to take it, there is no sign of the dreaded infodump here—instead, it’s just one amazing discovery after the other.
The characters are another highlight. I loved Ex, a young man who thrives on solitude, but finds his world turned upside down when he crosses paths with Arinya. Their shared experience on the road fosters a bond that transcends their initial circumstances, though their relationship does hit a few speedbumps along the way. The dialogue though was sublime and, in some cases, made me laugh out loud. Fantasy fiction involving demons and monster hunters often leans heavily into bleakness, which makes the unexpected humor a breath of fresh air.
Indeed, for a fun read that defies expectations, I highly recommend The Last Phi Hunter. The plot twists and turns on a wild journey that’s unpredictable as it is exciting. The Southeast Asian inspired world-building is particularly impressive and would delight readers who enjoy stories threaded with rich folklore and tales of mythological creatures. A must-read for anyone seeking an inventive, captivating fantasy adventure!
![]()
![]()
Book Review: To Gaze Upon Wicked Gods by Molly X. Chang
Posted on April 20, 2024 23 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
To Gaze Upon Wicked Gods by Molly X. Chang
Mogsy’s Rating: 3 of 5 stars
Genre: Fantasy
Series: Book 1 of Gods Beyond the Skies
Publisher: Del Rey (April 16, 2024)
Length: 368 pages
Author Information: Website
To Gaze Upon Wicked Gods by Molly X. Chang swings for the fences with an enemies-to-allies plot set in a world where its magically gifted denizens are ruled by their more technologically advanced conquerors. Yang Ruying is our protagonist, a woman “blessed by Death”, born with the ability to steal the life force from others with a touch. Many years ago, her home of Pangu, a fictional realm heavily influenced by Chinese culture and mythology, was invaded by colonizers from Rome who emerged from a portal in a sky and took over in a single day. Her people are further oppressed and controlled by the enemy with the introduction of a highly addictive and deadly drug known as Opian (yes, a heavy-handed allusion to opium) which keeps its users in a docile, languid state.
One day, a chance encounter on the street with the youngest Roman prince, Antony Augustus, leads to Ruying’s powers being exposed and her eventual capture by the Romans. Antony, however, offers her a deal which would ensure her safety and those she cares about—her twin sister and their grandmother—but only if she agrees to become his personal assassin by eliminating his political rivals. Ruying accepts reluctantly, but only after Antony convinces her that he is different from the rest of his family in that he genuinely wants to build a better Pangu to benefit both their peoples. But can a Roman really be trusted? Or is this simply Antony’s wily ploy to seize the throne? It’s a bargain that forces Ruying into a terrible choice, but as time passes, neither can she help or deny her deepening feelings for the charming prince.
While the core concept of this book is intriguing, its execution left me wanting more. Don’t get me wrong, there’s lots to like here. For instance, the story takes place in a world with a fascinating mix of elements, including a conquered population with lost magic, a dystopian setting with hints of historical colonialism, and a tenuous political alliance between two intriguing characters. That said though, many of these aspects felt undeveloped.
My main complaint is the vagueness of the world-building. Even with all the infodumps, I found it difficult to envision Pangu in my mind with its mix of sci-fi and fantasy components, because neither side was fleshed out completely. The details surrounding the magic system that encompasses Ruying and others’ powers are left mostly unexplained, and same goes for the Roman’s technology which was frustratingly hazy. This lack of clarity, combined with the inclusion of seemly random historical and cultural references to both Chinese dynasties and the Roman Empire felt neither here nor there, making the book’s entire concept feel disjointed. In my opinion, Chang could have created her own original societies and made her world more immersive while still achieving her same message. I’m also of the mind that authors should use foreign sayings sparingly, especially if you’re just going to translate them in the very next line. A touch of another language can add depth to the world-building, but too much makes it feel like superficial window dressing, not to mention it’s extremely distracting.
Also, I’m not sure if To Gaze Upon Wicked Gods was marketed as YA novel, but there are definitely elements of one. I have a sinking feeling that we are building towards a love triangle of sorts, though as others have mentioned, Ruying’s relationships with the two main men in her life are both kind of icky. But, to the author’s credit, I think there is great restraint being shown on the romance side of things which, despite its issues, wasn’t too intrusive.
To Gaze Upon Wicked Gods may be an ambitious but messy debut, but I think there is still potential here. The core conflict between love and duty is strong, and the plot itself is engaging. I will likely pick up the sequel to find out what happens next, and hopefully it will also smooth out some of the rougher edges.
![]()
![]()
Book Review: Immortal Pleasures by V. Castro
Posted on April 15, 2024 22 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
Immortal Pleasures by V. Castro
Mogsy’s Rating: 2.5 of 5 stars
Genre: Horror, Romance
Series: Stand Alone
Publisher: Del Rey (April 16, 2024)
Length: 304 pages
Author Information: Website
I probably should preface this review with a caveat: Immortal Pleasures by V. Castro is not going to be for everyone. It caters to a specific kind of reader, perhaps one who is a little more into the spicier side of things than I am. Apparently, the “seductive dark fantasy” blurb in the publisher description just means sex, sex, and more sex with barely a plotline to be glimpsed. But I’ll try to be fair.
First, the story. Centuries ago, when Spanish conquistador Hernan Cortez began his colonization of the Americas, he was helped by a Nahua woman who served as his translator. Known as La Malinche, she became branded as a traitor for her part in the eventual conquest and genocide of her own people. This book, however, offers an intriguing twist on history, reimagining her as an immortal vampire who now seeks vengeance on her old enemy. Reborn as Malinalli, she has taken on a personal mission to travel the world and reclaim stolen artifacts to their rightful countries and cultures.
Emotionally though, Malinalli feels empty. Her long years of wandering the globe by herself has made her long for love and connection, a yearning which leads her to Dublin, Ireland where she meets a human named Colin, a horror writer who immediately makes her his muse. The two begin a whirlwind romance, jet-setting off together on Malinalli’s hunt for a pair of Aztec skulls which have deep ties to her own traumatic past. But unexpectedly, fate throws another suitor her way, a fellow vampire who is much older and whose own quest may align with our protagonist’s.
To begin with the positives, I simply adore this cover. Very Queen of the Damned. The premise is also fascinating; I was not very familiar with the historical figure La Malinche, but after reading this book I went down a rabbit hole of looking up more information about her and I always like gaining new knowledge.
Unfortunately, the list of negatives is a bit longer. As alluded to earlier, the vibe is certainly striving to be Anne Rice-y but the writing is subpar with info dumps galore and disjointed prose with awkward, clunky descriptions occasionally resulting in unintentional hilarity especially during the sexually explicit sequences. Malinalli herself is completely unconvincing as a centuries-old vampire who supposedly travels around the world, with the emotional intelligence of someone with far less experience and maturity.
Finally, we arrive at the stuff where your mileage may vary. Obviously, a sexually explicit warning is a given. If you’re thirsting for a racy vampire romance and don’t mind sacrificing plot complexity and character depth for some hot and steamy content, this book could work for you. But those looking for a well-developed story will be left disappointed and feeling hollowed out.
Ultimately, this is a novel with a captivating concept, but subtlety and nuance are not its strongest points, and even the historical element was a bit weak. Still, managing expectations will be the key to your enjoyment. Bottom line, Immortal Pleasures occupies a specific niche of dark fantasy romance which won’t be everyone’s cup of tea but will delight its target audience.
![]()
![]()
Book Review: A Sweet Sting of Salt by Rose Sutherland
Posted on April 5, 2024 13 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
A Sweet Sting of Salt by Rose Sutherland
Mogsy’s Rating: 4.5 of 5 stars
Genre: Historical Fiction, Fantasy
Series: Stand Alone
Publisher: Dell (April 9, 2024)
Length: 352 pages
Author Information: Website
Sometimes, the best stories are the ones that catch you off guard. A Sweet Sting of Salt by Rose Sutherland wasn’t initially on my radar, but as soon as I found out about its premise, I knew I had to read it. Inspired by the classic legend of the Selkie Wife, this novel is a historical fiction retelling that combines a captivating blend of Celtic folklore, sapphic romance, and just a tiny dab of the fantastical.
The story opens in a small, Nova Scotian town in the early 1800s. It is a community of mostly farmers and fishermen, and our protagonist Jean is the only midwife for miles around. One stormy night, while getting ready for bed in her lonely seaside cottage, she hears a cry from outside and is shocked to see a pregnant young woman—clearly in labor—stumbling along the shore. After hustling the drenched woman indoors, Jean realizes she is speaking in a foreign tongue, hampering their ability to communicate. Despite this, Jean manages to get the woman to trust her, helping deliver her baby safely.
Gradually, Jean begins to piece together the mystery of the strange woman’s appearance. She finds out her name is Muirin, and that she must be the new wife of Tobias, who lives on the land next to Jean’s. Indeed, when Jean heads out the next morning to seek out her neighbor, she finds Tobias frantically searching for Muirin. When the couple are reunited, Tobias seemed relieved and overjoyed at the birth of his son, but Jean notices that Muirin’s behavior becomes guarded and closed off in the presence of her supposedly loving husband. Driven by a fierce protectiveness, Jean sets out to uncover Muirin’s secret past in order to keep her new friend and her baby safe.
At its core, A Sweet Sting of Salt is a heartwarming tale of unexpected love and connection. Jean is the main pillar of this novel, a fantastic protagonist on whom everything significant and amazing about this story is built. Harboring a secret herself, Jean is an ostracized member of her community because of a forbidden relationship she shared with a childhood friend which ended in disaster and heartbreak. Becoming a respected midwife was the second chance she cannot afford to lose, yet she would readily put aside her own needs for those whom she has given her loyalty and devotion.
The plot itself is evenly paced, and while the relationship between Jean and Muirin takes center stage, it is nevertheless handled subtly in a way that never overshadows the other elements in the book. The slow-burn romance is beautifully written with genuine emotional depth, allowing the characters’ bond to develop organically, making it all the more believable.
Finally, the wild and windswept shores of Nova Scotia lend a perfect vibe and Gothic atmosphere to the setting of this novel. In the author’s afterword, Sutherland writes about the very real places that inspired her, and this deep connection to her home can be experienced in the vivid descriptions of the that bring Jean and Muirin’s tale to life.
All told, A Sweet Sting of Salt is a delightful surprise and an impressive debut by Rose Sutherland. For fans of fiction inspired by classic folklore or readers looking for a unique historical novel with a touch of magic, look no further.
![]()
![]()
Book Review: The Trials of Empire by Richard Swan
Posted on April 1, 2024 18 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
The Trials of Empire by Richard Swan
Mogsy’s Rating: 5 of 5 stars
Genre: Fantasy
Series: Book 3 of Empire of the Wolf
Publisher: Orbit (February 6, 2024)
Length: 541 pages
Author Information: Website
Richard Swan’s epic Empire of the Wolf trilogy reaches its conclusion in The Trials of Empire, but this isn’t just your typical finale. It’s one I’ve been waiting for, for a long time. It’s no exaggeration when I say this is the best fantasy series I have read in years, and like any highly anticipated release, I was brimming with both nerves and excitement to get my hands on the final book. Now that I’ve read it, I’m happy to report my hopes have not been misplaced. A tad overlong it may be, but an ending like this can’t be rushed, and Swan has set a high bar for future authors.
The book plunges readers back into the turmoil of the Sovan Empire. The aftermath from the events of the previous installment, The Tyranny of Faith, continues to reverberate throughout the land. We follow our series narrator, Helena, and her mentor Justice Konrad Vonvalt and their companion Sir Radomir as they go on the run, trying to find sympathetic allies in their fight against the zealot Bartholomew Claver. Their search has led the group to the northern reaches, where the pagan clans still practice the old ways in defiance of the emperor and his Justices. However, the bad blood runs deep, and the clans don’t have much to lose and only freedoms to be gained if Sovan falls.
Thus, our characters are forced to turn their attention to the south, home to a mysterious civilization of wolfmen who have mostly kept to themselves. Having no love for Sova, any support they can give Vonvalt is limited, but their disdain for templars also means a willingness to listen, and it’s a start. Every moment they dally, Claver’s army draws closer to reaching its goal by meddling with supernatural malignant forces that have no business in the earthly realm.
The storytelling has always been on point in this series, but it rises to another level in The Trials of Empire. Once more we have Helena at the helm, recounting the events of her youth apprenticing and traveling with Vonvalt, her idealism acting as a counterpoint to the much older, more pragmatic and brooding Justice. Their dynamic creates a captivating tension, especially as Konrad becomes increasingly obsessed with saving the empire he loves, turning him to some questionable choices.
The plot also delivers on multiple fronts. While a few sections flagged in terms of pacing, these moments were fleeting as the rest of the novel drives towards the climax with pitch perfect tone and impeccable timing. The final battle contained some of the most intense sequences I’ve ever read. This last book also turns pretty dark, delving into territory and themes that won’t feel all that out of place in cosmic horror. Although Helena is no stranger to loss, she and her friends are pushed to some serious extremes in The Trials of Empire; everywhere they turn is more threat, more terror, and more brutality.
But my favorite part is the final act. Impactful without being too bombastic, the ending manages to tie up loose ends while leaving readers with a satisfying sense of closure. It is also fitting, given the themes of justice and the role that Vonvalt plays in the dispensing of it. Ultimately this series is a character study of a great man who is also fallible, which is why the focus on his relationship with Helena worked so well. Trying to apply the law in their imperfect world full of corruption is messy business, and Helena needed the time and experience to grow into the idea that her childhood hero is merely human.
My verdict? Consider this not just a recommendation but a strong request: read this trilogy. You won’t be disappointed by this stunning journey through a universe full of amazing people and cultures, intricate political machinations, and head-spinning plot twists. The Empire of the Wolf stands as a monument to the power of fantasy. I can’t wait to read more from Richard Swan.
![]()
![]()
More on The BiblioSanctum:
Review of The Justice of Kings (Book 1)
Review of The Tyranny of Faith (Book 2)
The Angel of Indian Lake by Stephen Graham Jones
Posted on March 28, 2024 16 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
The Angel of Indian Lake by Stephen Graham Jones
Mogsy’s Rating: 4.5 of 5 stars
Genre: Horror
Series: Book 3 of The Indian Lake trilogy
Publisher: Saga Press (March 26, 2024)
Length: 416 pages
Author Information: Website
The Angel of Indian Lake caps off the Indian Lake trilogy, picking up four years after the harrowing events of Don’t Fear the Reaper. The saga of our heroine Jade Daniels continues, and it’s recommended to read the books in order and be aware that the following review may contain spoilers for the previous books if you aren’t caught up yet.
As the story opens, readers are transported back to Proofrock, Idaho where Jade has also returned following a time of incarceration for past crimes committed. Bearing the physical and emotional scars of her sacrifices and trauma, she is determined to build a new life for herself with the help of her friend Letha Mondragon, whose clout has gotten Jade a job as a high school history teacher.
But with Halloween just around the corner, Proofrock is about to face another massacre. Jade is ready to move on, but unfortunately the town isn’t finished with her yet. The idyllic lake, once a source of beauty but now remembered as the site of so much devastation and bloodshed, now churns with the whispers of the Lake Witch curse. It’s a hair-raising reminder that Jade’s nightmare isn’t over. Armed with her encyclopedic knowledge of slasher flicks, she must rediscover her inner self and become someone who is more than just a final girl—a guardian angel who dares to believe redemption is possible.
The Angel of Indian Lake brings Jade’s saga to a close with a stunning final act which delivers a relentless onslaught of suspense and gore. Like the previous books, this one reads like a loving homage to classic horror movies, and through this framework author Stephen Graham Jones weaves his signature writing style. Fans familiar with his work can expect the practical effects that bring the chills and thrills to life, alongside heart-stopping sequences that keep you on your toes. The picturesque qualities of Proofrock take on a more sinister edge in this context, where terror waits around every corner.
But one of the highlights of the trilogy is undoubtedly Jade Daniels herself. She’s a complex and captivating protagonist. A survivor, not a victim. Despite her rejection of the hero label, she is in fact a kind of final girl, albeit an unconventional one that shatters the mold set by the typical slashers—which is kind of the point. I once again loved the meta-ness of the story, but also liked how the narrative never loses sight of the idea that Jade is a product of her experiences. For all that though, she refuses to be defined by the horrors in her past, and that fighting spirit is both tense and inspiring.
Of the three books in the series, The Angel of Indian Lake is also the bloodiest—probably. But it isn’t just brutal action and shocking twists. Beneath the surface is a more introspective layer that delves thoughtfully into the burdens of cultural heritage and legacy as well as its lasting effects. Jones holds no punches when it comes to violent and uncomfortable imagery, but It’s the emotional depth, a glaring contrast to the blood and gore, that truly elevates this concluding volume by offering a glimmer of hope.
The Angel of Indian Lake is certainly well worth the read for the satisfying ending, but fans of well-written horror in general should also take note, especially if you are a horror film buff. Stephen Graham Jones successfully incorporates classic genre tropes while simultaneously turning them on their head in this fantastic and unique trilogy, and I’m excited to see what he’ll serve up next.
![]()
![]()
More on The BiblioSanctum:
Review of My Heart is a Chainsaw (Book 1)
Review of Don’t Fear the Reaper (Book 2)















































