DNF Roundup
A little follow-up to my DNF roundup from a couple weeks ago, featuring the rest of the books that landed on my abandoned pile during the whirlwind of late summer and early fall. These are a few more reads that, for one reason or another, just didn’t hold my interest enough to keep going. As always, your mileage may vary!
I received review copies from the publisher(s). This does not affect the contents of my reviews and all opinions are my own.
Winterset Hollow by Jonathan Edward Durham
Mogsy’s Rating: DNF
Genre: Fantasy, Horror
Series: Stand Alone
Publisher: Union Square & Co. (October 6, 2026)
Length: 400 pages
I thought Winterset Hollow would be right up my alley, with its dark fairy-tale atmosphere and mysterious setting. In it, three friends get to travel to the world of their favorite book from childhood, only to discover that not only are its characters very real, they are also not quite as innocent as they seem. Unfortunately, despite an intriguing setup, I found the story pretty slow going and struggled to get invested in the world or the characters. Then all of a sudden, things take a bizarre and bloody turn, transforming from Wind in the Willows to full on Cocaine Bear. Of course, by that point I’d already lost interest. I gave this book a little more than halfway before deciding that I don’t mind weird or over-the-top horror, but I do need to care about what’s happening first. Still, the way this novel exploded in popularity from its humble self-published roots is a testament to the readers who loved it, so give it a try if it interests you.
‘Twas the Night by Kevin Johnson
Mogsy’s Rating: DNF
Genre: Horror
Series: Stand Alone
Publisher: William Morrow Paperbacks (October 13, 2026)
Length: 279 pages
This one I figured would be a blast to pick up in that stretch between Halloween and Christmas, when I’m in the mood for a little festive horror. After all, if The Nightmare Before Christmas has taught us anything, it’s that the combination of these two holidays can go together surprisingly well. The premise certainly sounded good, with an evil Santa and a creepy little Christmas town in the middle of nowhere. The story follows a reporter investigating a string of missing children who finds herself in Yule, Maine, where Christmas is practically a religion and Santa Claus is very much real. However, I found the execution a little awkward. I think my biggest issue is that the book seems caught between wanting to be funny and wanting to be genuinely scary, but it never quite commits to either. The humor didn’t do anything for me, and the horror never went quite far enough. The result felt more silly than entertaining. If Christmas-themed horror is your jam, you might have a better time with this one than I did, but even its short length wasn’t enough to keep me reading.
Cold Empty Rooms by Andy Marino
Mogsy’s Rating: DNF
Genre: Horror
Series: Stand Alone
Publisher: Run For It (November 10, 2026)
Length: 384 pages
This is my second book by Andy Marino, and while I know his work can get a little weird, I enjoyed The Swarm enough that I wanted to check out more of his writing.
Except Cold Empty Rooms was a very different experience! It follows Mara and Soren, a couple looking for a fresh start who end up in a creepy, rundown house. When they begin receiving strange messages from an unknown entity, the two decide to open their home to others who, like them, have nowhere else to turn. Beyond that, it’s hard to really describe the story because, well, to me, it didn’t feel like there was much of one. After almost a quarter of the way in and still no real plot in sight, I found the book to be little more than a bunch of characters and interactions that didn’t particularly interest me. Many of the people were either bland or downright unlikeable, which made it even more difficult to get invested in their thoughts and conversations. While I can admire the time and effort put into a good setup, this one just wasn’t giving me enough reason to stick around, and in the end I had to set it aside and move on to something a little more stimulating.










