Book Review: Songbird of the Sorrows by Braidee Otto

I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.

Songbird of the Sorrows by Braidee Otto

Mogsy’s Rating: 3.5 of 5 stars

Genre: Romance, Fantasy

Series: Book 1 of Myths of the Empyrieos

Publisher: The Dial Press (February 3, 2026)

Length: 400 pages

Author Information: Website

Even if you’re just a casual reader of YA or New Adult romantasy, I think Songbird of the Sorrows by Braidee Otto will instantly feel familiar. You have your secret princess, a shadowy network of spies, and a dangerous mission that places the protagonist in a “last one standing” style competition against others. It’s the kind of setup that immediately signals the types of tropes this story is interested in exploring.

The novel follows Aella, a king’s daughter cast out of the palace at a young age and raised instead in the Aviary, a school for orphans which is in fact a front for an organization that trains its students to become covert operatives for the Empyrieos. After completing years of training, successful graduates of the program are given new identities and code names inspired by birds. For example, when Aella finally earns her place among the full-fledged members, she takes the name of Starling and is given her first major assignment as part of the Aviary’s elite unit, Alpha Flight.

This mission sends her straight into enemy territory under the guise of competing in the bridal trials hosted by the Prince of Eretria to choose his future queen. Having been born a princess, Aella already possesses many of the skills expected of a highborn lady thanks to her early palace upbringing, making her return to the role of Princess of the Sorrows a natural fit. Combined with the spycraft and combat training she received at the Aviary, she becomes a serious contender in the trials. Beneath all the spectacle, however, Alpha Flight’s true objective is to gather intelligence and support a larger operation led by Raven, a senior agent with whom Aella shares a complicated past—one that only heightens the tension as she struggles to maintain her cover and survive the cruel prince’s dangerous games at court.

As the story unfolds, Aella is pulled in several directions at once. It doesn’t help that the bridal trials themselves function less as a The Bachelor style competition and more as a backdrop for political maneuvering and espionage. Unfortunately, the biggest hurdle for me was the journey it took to this point where hints are finally revealed about the larger power struggles beneath the surface. To put bluntly, the first half of the novel is a collection of clichés, from the emotional blackmail that drives Aella to perform her task to the absolute cringiness of a group of ladies competing for the hand of a prince. For one, Aella is threatened with her beloved friend’s death should she fail, and this is one device that has always bothered me. Our protagonist is clearly capable, but the story takes a while to let her feel like she’s acting for herself rather than being pushed from one obligation to the next.

The good news is, things improve drastically in the back half of the book. Once the groundwork is out of the way, the plot becomes more engaging and less predictable. Secondary characters start to stand out, the suspense surrounding the court intrigue sharpens, with the broader implications of Alpha Flight’s mission becoming clearer. The focus turns towards unpacking the secrets, while the big yikes situation between the bridal competitors begins to develop real momentum beyond banal pageantry. By the final page, the author has delivered an ending that hooks the readers and makes the larger series feel worth sticking with.

On a final note though, the writing tends to be on the purple side, and it didn’t surprise me to find out that Songbird of the Sorrows is a debut. On top of the plot being very ambitious and occasionally frazzled, at times the prose feels overwritten with “first novel” energy—as in just a tad too excessive with the flowery metaphors. Hopefully, that will soon turn into a cleaner style with Braidee Otto’s later books because I can see a lot of potential in this series. As a first installment, this is a solid if uneven start, but it’s also a beginning that hints at a stronger follow-up down the line!