Thriller Thursday Audio: The Girl Beneath the Sea by Andrew Mayne

I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.

The Girl Beneath the Sea by Andrew Mayne

Mogsy’s Rating (Overall): 4 of 5 stars

Genre: Mystery, Thriller

Series: Book 1 of Underwater Investigation Unit

Publisher: Brilliance Audio (May 1, 2020)

Length: 9 hrs and 16 mins

Author Information: Website | Twitter

Narrator: Susannah Jones

Well, it’s not The Naturalist, but still so good! What’s also pretty awesome is that last summer I caught the author on the Discovery Channel Shark Week special Andrew Mayne: Ghost Diver, and now I can’t help but wonder how much of his experience doing for that show had ended up influencing this book. Plus I believe I read somewhere that Mayne grew up among scuba divers and law enforcement, so when I first learned about The Girl Beneath the Sea, I became curious to see how he would incorporate those ideas and concepts into this new thriller.

As the opening volume to a new series, The Girl Beneath the Sea begins by whisking readers off to the south Florida coast where protagonist Sloan McPherseon works for the Lauderdale Shores police department as an evidence recovery diver. On a routine dive in the canal one day, she comes across a recently dead body in the water—a woman who must have been killed and dumped not moments before Sloan got there. Unfortunately, that timing was just a coincidence too great for the police to ignore, landing Sloan on their suspects list. Of course, it also doesn’t help that she comes from family of eccentric treasure hunters and drug smugglers, with an uncle who’s in prison. Then comes an even greater shock—it turns out that the dead woman had a connection to Sloan’s past, making the authorities even more suspicious.

Now the only one who can help her is the McPhersons’ greatest enemy. George Solar is the DEA agent whose testimony had been pivotal in putting Sloan’s uncle behind bars all those years ago, and the memories of how that had devastated her family are still fresh in her mind. Solar’s history, however, has also been known to be rather shady, which means he may have the knowledge and connections to help Sloan out of her mess, leaving her with no choice but to trust him. As the two of them team up to investigate the murder though, they stumble into a vast conspiracy brewing amidst widespread corruption, and the deeper they dig, the more they may be putting both themselves and their loved ones in possible peril.

While it’s definitely tempting to compare The Girl Beneath the Sea with Mayne’s Naturalist series, I realize it’s not that simple. The two are very different, for one, and quite honestly I think that’s a good thing. Ultimately, I would love to see Underwater Investigation Unit establish its own identity as a series and stand on its own merits, and based on this first installment, I think it’s off to a great start. The good news is that we also don’t sacrifice any of the over-the-top action and thrills that are the hallmarks of the author’s books, though the difference is, The Girl Beneath the Sea reads more like a police procedural in its structure and pacing, emphasizing law enforcement and interagency detective work. The storytelling style itself is very similar to the crime dramas you might see on primetime TV.

Since it’s Florida, there are also gators, sharks, and the drug war. Sloan and Solar’s battle with the cartels and corruption among the ranks might not prove as thrilling for some, but to me the plot was fast-paced and exciting. As well, Sloan is a great character, maybe a bit rough around the edges. Like many of the author’s protagonists, her greatest fault seems to be her impulsivity and tendency to act quickly with little consideration of the consequences (but hey, that’s what makes his books so fun, right?) I ended up liking Sloan, despite the fact she’s a bit of a maverick and one hell of a troublemaker, mainly due to her courageous spirit and her big heart which makes up for her shortcomings. She’s also a single mom in a family with a lot of quirky members and complicated relationships, as you might imagine given the McPhersons’ history with the law and Sloan’s career with the police. Throw in her prickly situation with Solar as well, and you just know there will be no end to the surprises.

What all this means is, if you’re into Andrew Mayne’s clever, funny, and over-the-top style, I think you will also enjoy The Girl Beneath the Sea. In a way, I think the novel’s premise actually makes it more plausible than many of his other works (relatively), but the approach he takes to the crime drama procedural is certainly still unique and very interesting. Bottom line, this was an entertaining adventure and I had a hell of time. It also looks like the sequel Black Coral already has a cover, synopsis, and release date, so I guess I’ll be circling my calendar and waiting not so patiently!

Audiobook Comments: I listened to the audiobook edition, a decision I don’t regret at all. I often find that thrillers are more effective in this format especially when you have a good narrator, and Susannah Jones completely nailed it. Everything about her performance was outstanding, from her voices to her timing. She kept me hanging on every word, ending up making me stay up way past my usual bedtime so I could find out how the book ended. So if you’re considering The Girl Beneath the Sea, I do highly recommend this one in audio.

19 Comments on “Thriller Thursday Audio: The Girl Beneath the Sea by Andrew Mayne”

  1. While I had my problems with the first – and so far only – book in the Naturalist series, I was intrigued by your comment about the higher level of plausibility in this new novel, which might be the element that will compel me to give this author another chance. Who knows? You might have helped me change my mind… 😉
    Thanks for sharing!


  2. Pingback: Mogsy’s Bookshelf Roundup 05/23/20: Stacking the Shelves & Recent Reads | The BiblioSanctum

  3. It’s great to hear you enjoyed this. In your description of the story I can see similarities to the Naturalist series, both in aspects of the story and in characters. And I think that’s fine if he keeps it fresh and exciting, which it sounds like he has. It’s funny, reading his books so far I sometimes start to get nervous he’s going in a direction I’m going to tire of, that he’s going just a bit too far over the top, or the character is becoming a bit too arrogant, all things that I used to see happen with longer running tv shows. And yet, in each case he’s managed to take the story right up to that line and not go over it (at least my version of that line). So I’ve continued enjoying each of his books. Hopefully I’ll get to this one, as well. Thanks for a great review.


    • I worry about that too, like with every Theo Cray book I have to wonder…where can we go next? He’s already pulled out all the stops! It’ll be interesting to see where he takes the next book though, given how the last one ended. But I wonder if we’ll see it soon, since it seems in the last year he has been concentrating on this series :\


  4. Ooooh, I didn’t realize this was by the same guy who wrote The Naturalist. I was excited by the plot, but that’s interesting, too. I just grabbed the audio since they have a whispersync deal for it.


  5. Yeah, I agree that thrillers can be great at audio. Glad you liked this one! I’m slowly collecting recs from you for whenever I’m in the mood for a thriller. This one goes on the list. 🙂


  6. Pingback: Audiobook Review: Black Coral by Andrew Mayne | The BiblioSanctum

  7. Pingback: Audiobook Review: Sea Storm by Andrew Mayne | The BiblioSanctum

  8. Pingback: Audiobook Review: Sea Storm by Andrew Mayne – Imobiliare 24

  9. Pingback: Audiobook Review: Sea Storm by Andrew Mayne – Book Library

  10. Pingback: Off the Charts – the girl beneath the sea (Andrew Mayne) – Captain's Quarters

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: