YA Weekend: Daughter of Smoke & Bone by Laini Taylor

4c87c-daughterofsmokeandboneDaughter of Smoke & Bone by Laini Taylor

Genre: Young Adult, Supernatural, Romance, Urban Fantasy

Series: Daughter of Smoke & Bone #1

Publisher: Little Brown Books (September 2011)

Author Info:  www.lainitaylor.com

Wendy’s Rating: 3 of 5 stars

Karou is a nice, blue-haired enigma living in Prague and attending art school where her friends love to see her sketchbooks. In those books are beautiful images of fantastical creatures–human and beast, woven together like tapestries–and she has elaborate tales to go with every image on every page.

The thing is, the stories she tells about those creatures are as real as the creatures themselves, because Karou’s family happen to be a bunch of chimera. Karou is well aware that this is not exactly normal, but, having no clue about anything else about herself, she accepts it as how her life works. Until the angels arrive to literally burn things down.

Taylor’s world is incredible, and I love the tantalizing unveiling of the age-old struggle between the chimera and the angels, with neither side clearly being good or evil and poor Karou caught in the middle of it. The only thing that could make this aspect of the book better is if it included a full gallery of Karou’s work.

Unfortunately, the story starts to fall apart for me right about the time that the angel Akiva appears. He is beautiful beyond all understanding, and Karou is drawn to him as he is to her, even though they are enemies. Uh oh. Forbidden love alarm bells! I love a good Romeo and Juliet story, but this one just wasn’t it. When the two start to obviously fall for each other, the feisty Karou is replaced by the lonely Karou in desperate need of someone to call her own, while Akiva, who gets to tell the story from his own point of view as well, is the wounded angel who once knew the love of the enemy and is falling for it again.

Back to the part about the angels burning things down. The book takes on all the signs of a pending apocalypse when the angels reveal themselves to humanity, fighting this battle on earth instead of in other realms as it has been in the past. While we do get a few glimpses of the damage and excitement that results, that all becomes background noise as Akiva and Karou go on dates to get to know each other. Okay, it’s not that trite, but it feels a bit like that at times when they are hanging out at coffee houses after epic street battles–even if the people do believe it to be just an elaborate street performance.

Once we learn about Akiva’s past, the connection to Karou becomes obvious and so the big reveal–which is dragged out to frustrating levels–isn’t such a surprise. It’s also where the book falters further, slowing the pace to give us the truth about Karou in more forbidden love angst, complete with potential love triangle concerns.

By the end, I was disappointed. So much potential in a unique story about angels and demons and their war, but it all just ends up as a banal young adult love story. Despite the second big reveal (again, dragged out and unsurprising), there is promise for things to get interesting, but I have so little desire to hang out with Karou and Akiva much further.


11 Comments on “YA Weekend: Daughter of Smoke & Bone by Laini Taylor”

  1. It’s too bad the story changed for you with the arrival of the character. I confess that I’m quite curious about this series because I keep hearing amazing things about it.


    • It was one of those “I wanted to like this” situations, but I think I prefer the relationship in Angelfall better. That one was more organic, while this one was forced. The chemistry was initially unbelieveable, and when the reason for it is revealed, it takes away from Karou herself, I found.


  2. I think a lot of people shared your frustration with the Karou/Akiva relationship, Wendy (although admittedly I wasn’t one of them!). The instant attraction between them definitely threw me until their backstory was revealed. Even with that weirdness I still loved this book – there were too many priceless quotes for me not to. Like the one about “non-essential penises,” haha. Pure gold.


    • There was definitely a lot to like!

      My issue with the insta-ttraction was compounded when Karou was taken away and replaced with Madrigal. Madrigal lacked Karou’s charisma, and that just sapped everything from the story for me.

      Still, she makes a choice at the end that could lead to some interesting places and allow the relationship to continue in a more organic manner.


Leave a Reply to Lisa (@TenaciousReader) Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: