Book Review: Cold Magic by Kate Elliott
Genre: Fantasy
Series: Book 1 of Spiritwalker
Publisher: Orbit (September 2, 2010)
Mogsy’s Rating: 3 of 5 stars
The positive things I’ve heard about Kate Elliott’s books, especially praise for her Crossroads trilogy, have always piqued my curiosity and made me feel like I’m missing out for not having read any of her work. So when I saw the Cold Magic ebook on sale a few months back, I snapped it up and didn’t even hesitate for a second.
From its description, the book sounded like it would be right up my alley. Dawn of a new age? An Industrial Revolution which heralds inventions and technologies never seen before? Throw in a young, educated heroine caught up in the middle of this movement, and I thought it was going to be a winner for sure.
In many ways, I was correct. This is undoubtedly a good book. The story is an intricate web of political intrigue and hidden truths, taking place in a world that is practically overwhelming with its multiple facets. And Catherine “Cat” Hassi Barahal is a headstrong protagonist, embarking on a perilous adventure to find out who she really is. All in all, I was quite enchanted by this novel and all the wondrous magic, people and creatures Cat encountered on her journey.
And yet, I can’t shake the feeling that this book could have been so much more. I wanted it to be great; I wanted to be amazed, but something always stopped me just short of getting to that point. After a while, I was finally able to pin down why I felt this way. Essentially, everything I mentioned before — the fascinating characters, setting, and plot — all started out on the right track, but ultimately never seemed to reach their potential.
Perhaps the most frustrating of those for me is the setting, which had everything going for it with its steampunky flavor and even an alternate spirit realm. I was intrigued by the idea of a clash between magic and science, between the old and the new, but unfortunately what I’d hoped for never really materialized. Don’t get me wrong; it’s a complex and imaginative world, but it somehow lacked coherence. Incidentally, I felt much the same way about the story, which started losing its momentum after a strong introduction, in part due to the lack of clear direction.
I also felt ambivalent towards Cat. I didn’t dislike her but I didn’t like her either, and therein lies the problem. It’s hard to fully appreciate a book when the protagonist fails to interest me. Even now I can think of very little to say about her, except that I didn’t really care for the way she was drawn to Andevai. Among my biggest pet peeves is when heroines fall for men who treat them badly, and Cat dances dangerously close to that line. Here’s a man who snatches her from her home, speaks to her gruffly, and is an all around cold, arrogant jerk. By all rights she should want nothing to do with him, and yet he is shaping up to be the love interest.
I guess I’ll just have to wait to find out what happens. Though I liked this book well enough, I’m also not in any hurry to pick up the sequel. I’m certainly not writing this series off yet, but I have a feeling my next Kate Elliott book will probably be something else. After all, I have heard that her Spiritwalker series is very different from her previous work, and who knows, perhaps I’ll check out the Crossroads trilogy first.
The BiblioSanctum 