Bookshelf Roundup 12/10/23: Stacking the Shelves & Recent Reads
Posted on December 10, 2023 23 Comments
Bookshelf Roundup is a feature I do every weekend which fills the role of several blog memes, like Stacking the Shelves where I talk about the new books I’ve added to my library or received for review, as well as It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? where I summarize what I’ve finished reading in the last week and what I’m planning to read soon. Mostly it also serves as a recap post, so sometimes I’ll throw in stuff like reading challenge progress reports, book lists, and other random bookish thoughts or announcements.

Received for Review
My thanks to the publishers and authors for the following review copies received, and be sure to click the links to their Goodreads pages for more details and full descriptions!
A Sweet Sting of Salt by Rose Sutherland (Dell): I mean, I love folklore inspired stories, but selkies?! Give it to me now.
The Briar Book of the Dead by A.G. Slatter (Titan Books): I’m a big fan of Angela Slatter’s gorgeous writing, and I don’t get a chance to read as many of her books as I’d like to. I’m really excited to check this one out.
A Botanical Daughter by Noah Medlock (Titan Books): This beautiful book arrived this week, and how can I resist this horror debut described as Mexican Gothic meets The Lie Tree by way of Oscar Wilde and Mary Shelley?
Island Witch by Amanda Jayatissa (Berkley): A gothic fantasy inspired by Sri Lankan folklore, this is historical novel infused with horror, mystery, and witchcraft.
The House that Horror Built by Christina Henry (Berkley): The author’s books have been hit or miss for me these past few years, but I do want to give this one a chance. What can I say, haunted houses and horror movies are my weakness.
Reviews
Recent Reads
I didn’t read too much this week, as I was feeling a little antsy and couldn’t quite figure out what I wanted to pick up next. Of course, this being my catch-up month, I had a bit of leeway to choose what I wanted so I went with some mood reads. One turned out to be a bust which I ended up DNFing, so that was a bit of time wasted (at the end of the year, I may do an inaugural post featuring a round up of my DNFs, of which there are going to be at least three). Happily, things started looking up after that. Ultimately, I went with Chasing the Boogeyman by Richard Chizmar which wasn’t even a review book, but I loved the idea of “true crime fiction” and it ended being a winner. Still feeling the mystery vibe, I next picked up Dead of Winter by Darcy Coates which is one of my review books from earlier this summer, and again it was exactly what I was looking for.
![]()
Have you heard of or read any of the books featured this week? What caught your eye? Any new discoveries? I hope you found something interesting for a future read!
Audiobook Review: The Mystery Guest by Nita Prose
Posted on December 8, 2023 14 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
The Mystery Guest by Nita Prose
Mogsy’s Rating (Overall): 4.5 of 5 stars
Genre: Mystery
Series: Book 2 of Molly the Maid
Publisher: Random House Audio (November 28, 2023)
Length: 8 hrs and 23 mins
Author Information: Website
Narrator: Lauren Ambrose
Nita Prose’s debut The Maid was a surprise hit and one of my favorite gems of 2022. I was very excited when I learned that a sequel was in the works, but does the second Molly Gray mystery live up to the first? Yes!
The Mystery Guest takes readers back into the refined world of our charming but unconventional protagonist. Growing up, Molly always knew she was different. She doesn’t communicate well, struggling to read social cues and seemingly saying the wrong things all the time. Her only confidant and the one person in the world who understood her was her grandmother, but after Gran died, Molly was on her own. Fortunately, her job as a maid at the esteemed Regency Grand Hotel allowed her to put her fastidious ways to good use, making sure every wealthy guest is treated to a room in a state of perfection. She might not be the best conversationalist, but she’s damn good at her job, which has helped her rise through the ranks to become Head Maid.
However, Molly’s life takes a dramatic turn when one of the Regency Grand’s guests, a famous mystery author by the name of J.D. Grimthorpe, quite literally keels over dead in the hotel tearoom, apparently poisoned. The ensuing investigation is led by Detective Stark, an old adversary of Molly’s who once suspected her of murder, and who again believes our protagonist might have something to do with the author’s untimely death. To clear her name as well as to save her beloved hotel’s reputation, Molly decides to take matters into her own hands by pursuing leads, interviewing suspects, and digging back into her own past. It appears she has a link to the deceased, as her grandmother used to work as a cleaner for Grimthorpe. It’s a longshot, but Molly’s own memories of her childhood accompanying Gran to the novelist’s mansion may ultimately hold the key to solving his murder.
Oh how I love Molly! Her character resonates with a combination of charm and resilience, but what truly endears her to me is her unique personality. The author paints a genuine picture of Molly, as our protagonist emerges as a compelling and believable individual made up of distinctive behaviors, mannerisms, and expressions that set her apart.
The luxurious backdrop of a high-end hotel also proves to be an ideal setting for this sort-of cozy mystery. The lavishness of the situation provides the perfect stage, with the characters seamlessly sliding into the various archetypal roles that wouldn’t feel out of place in a classic murder mystery. And yet, despite calling to mind the timeless genre archetypes I’ve come to know and love, every side character also brings a fresh new perspective. The result is a narrative that feels contemporarily quirky but also infused with a nostalgic, old timey charm.
This sequel also delves further into the relationship between Molly and Gran, exploring through flashbacks their time working together in Grimthorpe’s home. These sections looking back into the past are a major side plot in their own right, adding a poignant layer to the story. These glimpses into Molly’s childhood not only provide insight into her character but also an emotionally charged element about love and family.
In sum, if you enjoyed The Maid, then there’s a good chance you’ll love its follow-up The Mystery Guest as well. Once more, readers are treated to a scintillating mystery, but in my opinion, this novel also includes greater emotional depth than its predecessor with its touching exploration of Molly’s childhood growing up with a loving and protective guardian like Gran. Nita Prose skillfully combines the modern and the classic, resulting in this sequel that was a joy to read and listen to, with Lauren Ambrose reprising her role as audiobook narrator and giving the perfect voice to the characters.
![]()
![]()
More on The BiblioSanctum:
Review of The Maid (Book 1)
Waiting on Wednesday 12/06/23
Posted on December 6, 2023 8 Comments
Waiting On Wednesday” is a weekly meme that first originated at Breaking the Spine but has since linked up with “Can’t Wait Wednesday” at Wishful Endings now that the original creator is unable to host it anymore. Either way, this fun feature is a chance to showcase the upcoming releases that we can’t wait to get our hands on!
Mogsy’s Pick
Winter Lost by Patricia Briggs (June 18, 2024 by Ace)
“Mercy Thompson, car mechanic and shapeshifter, must stop a disaster of world-shattering proportions in this exhilarating entry in the No. 1 New York Times bestselling series.
In the supernatural realms, there are creatures who belong to winter. I am not one of them. But like the coyote I can become at will, I am adaptable.
My name is Mercy Thompson Hauptman, and my mate, Adam, is the werewolf who leads the Columbia Basin Pack, the pack charged with keeping the people who live and work in the Tri-Cities of Washington State safe. It’s a hard job, and it doesn’t leave much room for side quests. Which is why when I needed to travel to Montana to help my brother, I intended to go by myself.
But I’m not alone anymore.
Together, Adam and I find ourselves trapped with strangers in a lodge in the heart of the wilderness, in the teeth of a storm of legendary power, only to discover my brother’s issues are a tiny part of a problem much bigger than we could have imagined. Arcane and ancient magics are at work that could, unless we are very careful, bring about the end of the world . . .”
Audiobook Review: Night Owl by Andrew Mayne
Posted on December 5, 2023 7 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
Mogsy’s Rating (Overall): 3.5 of 5 stars
Genre: Mystery, Thriller
Series: Book 1 of Trasker
Publisher: Brilliance Audio (December 1, 2023)
Length: 8 hrs and 5 mins
Author Information: Website
Narrator: James Anderson Foster
As an avid fan of Andrew Mayne, my enthusiasm led me to request his latest book Night Owl without looking too closely at its description. As a result, I was surprised to discover it was a spy thriller, a genre I typically don’t gravitate towards. Adjusting to this narrative distinct from the author’s usual over-the-top style was initially challenging and a bit jarring, admittedly, but ultimately I found Night Owl to be a solid addition to its genre.
The book follows Brad Trasker, a retired counterintelligence agent who, after spending decades in the field, finds himself jaded and disillusioned while dealing with the tragic loss of his son. He thought his days of playing spy games were long over, until he was invited to the launch of an experimental aircraft by a cutting-edge aerospace company headed by CEO Kylie Connor. During the launch, the aircraft explodes, causing much destruction to the launch area and nearly kills Kylie, leading Trasker to wonder: Was the explosion merely an unfortunate accident, or was it sabotage and directed assassination?
Suddenly, Traskerfinds himself pulled back into the dangerous world he thought he had left behind. The mystery surrounding the explosion quickly becomes more complex as it is discovered that all of Kylie’s precious research data has been tampered with, and one of her engineers goes missing. As the first bodies begin piling up, it is clear that both she and the future of her company are in jeopardy, targeted by an unknown enemy. To root out the mastermind behind this plot, Trasker must find out what they want with Kylie, even as the CEO herself becomes suspect.
Reading Night Owl was definitely a different experience coming from Mayne’s other works. That said, even as the novel adheres closely to the trajectory and tone of a conventional spy thriller, it still undoubtedly carries a bit of the author’s signature flair. For one, the action was nothing short of electrifying. Mayne masterfully crafts scenes that pulse with tension, putting his characters in situations that keep readers on the edge of their seats. He’s clearly adapted well to the genre, weaving intrigue into the fabric of the story, building it up layer by layer to create an atmosphere of suspense that lingers throughout.
Granted, many of these sequences are also handled with more solemnity and a self-possessed presence than I’m normally used to from Mayne’s previous books, though I believe this has a lot to do with Night Owl’s protagonist. Brad Trasker stands apart with a personality shaped by his many years working as a spy, and it reflects a mix of seasoned professionalism, resilience, and a haunted past. He takes his job seriously, carrying a certain world-weariness about him, having faced nearly everything the world of counterintelligence could throw his way. This in turn sets the tone for the novel, which exhibits the same sense of purpose shown by Trasker as he navigates the many challenges that arise through the story.
However, this does mean that Night Owl also has its share of obstacles, one of them being its unbalanced pacing. The story does take a while to hit its stride as the initial build-up feels a bit sluggish, with the intro sections of the novel making me wish it had a stronger and more immediate hook. Overall, it did strike me as lacking the usual pulse-quickening tempo that I’ve come to anticipate from Mayne.
But while Night Owl might have been a touch slow off the mark, once the plot finds its rhythm, the narrative chugs on, becoming an exciting blend of mystery, intrigue, and espionage that spycraft fans will find addictive. In the end, the novel shows off Andrew Mayne’s versatility and writing talents to deliver riveting action and well-crafted characters. Yes, the initial pacing might require a bit of patience, but the payoff’s well worth your time. Credit is also due to James Anderson Foster, the audiobook narrator whose performance and voice work greatly enhanced the listening experience.
![]()
![]()
Bookshelf Roundup 12/03/23: Stacking the Shelves & Recent Reads
Posted on December 3, 2023 14 Comments
Bookshelf Roundup is a feature I do every weekend which fills the role of several blog memes, like Stacking the Shelves where I talk about the new books I’ve added to my library or received for review, as well as It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? where I summarize what I’ve finished reading in the last week and what I’m planning to read soon. Mostly it also serves as a recap post, so sometimes I’ll throw in stuff like reading challenge progress reports, book lists, and other random bookish thoughts or announcements.

Received for Review
My thanks to the publishers and authors for the following review copies received, and be sure to click the links to their Goodreads pages for more details and full descriptions!
Wicked Problems by Max Gladstone (Tordotcom): The second book of The Craft Wars, from the world of The Craft Sequence which I loved, though I just realized I hadn’t read the first book. A problem that will be rectified post haste.
Like It Never Happened by Jeff Hoffman (Crooked Lane Books): The publisher has been surprising me lately with their horror and thriller selections. When I was pitched this psychological suspense about a group of high school friends reunite years later to keep a terrible secret hidden, I was intrigued.
Three Kinds of Lucky by Kim Harrison (Ace): I was beyond excited for this arrival this week! I’ve always been curious about the author’s Hollows novels, and this first book in The Shadow Age series seems like a good jumping on point to try her work.
Bride by Ali Hazelwood (Berkley): A vampire and werewolf story of forbidden love might not sound like the most original tale, but I do love how quirky this sounds and am looking forward to see how the author will turn beloved tropes on their head.
The House of Last Resort by Christopher Golden (Minotaur): I can never resist a haunted house story, especially one set in the hilltop town of Becchina, Italy. To rebuild his crumbling town, the mayor has offered to sell abandoned homes to anyone in the world for a single Euro, as long as the buyer promses to live there for at least five years. A young American couple decides to bite, leading to terrifying results.
Reviews
Recent Reads
Another Sci-fi Month has wrapped up and I probably didn’t do as much as I wanted, though not for lack of trying. There simply weren’t too many science fiction releases I was excited about this year, maybe next year will be a little better for the genre. In the meantime, as we welcome December AKA unofficial “Catchup Month,” I got to finish a couple books that have been waiting for their turn since early fall, including The Graveyard Shift (which had a great premise but was riddled with issues) as well as The Paleontologist (which was better than I thought). I also finished Night Owl, which released at the beginning of this month, so expect a review real soon.
![]()
Have you heard of or read any of the books featured this week? What caught your eye? Any new discoveries? I hope you found something interesting for a future read!
Top Ten Science Fiction Reads of 2023
Posted on November 30, 2023 19 Comments
As we get ready to say good bye to another year of Sci-Fi Month, it’s time again to put together a list of my top ten science fiction books that I’ve had the pleasure to read in 2023!
Rubicon by J.S. Dewes
When the story opens, we are introduced to Sergeant Adrienne Valero, who is about to die for the 96th time. The scene is total pandemonium as a bloody battle rages everywhere, and Valero and her squad are losing badly to the Mechans, an army of intelligent machines controlled by a hivemind that humans have been at war with for decades. Despite putting up a valiant fight, at the end of the first chapter, our protagonist is killed only to resurrect at the beginning of the next chapter, using cutting-edge technology that can restore the dead to life in a new body via a process known as “rezoning.” While being able to cheat death like this has given humanity a huge advantage in the conflict against the tireless Mechan, there’s no question that having been rezoned close to a hundred times has taken its toll on Valero. She no longer bats an eye at new assignments anymore, knowing she’ll sent to yet another battlefield to fight, to die, to be reborn again, and to do it over and over again until the war ends, whenever that may be. It’s hard to care about anything when you’re living a life like this, when everything seems pointless and devoid of hope. Rubicon is one of the most enjoyable military sci-fi novels I’ve read in a while—probably since Dewes’ The Last Watch, as a matter of fact! That it is also a standalone is a huge plus. (Read the full review…)
Antimatter Blues by Edward Ashton
Coming on the heels of Mickey7 is the sequel Antimatter Blues, which is as off-the-hook and irreverent as its predecessor. If you liked the first book, I think you will find this follow-up just as good, and in some respects even better. Approximately two years have passed since Mickey Barnes’ retirement. He has a girlfriend and works as a general laborer, spending his days cleaning out rabbit hutches. Compared to his old job, this was heaven, and it’s all because Commander Marshall, the colony’s leader, believes that Mickey had given an antimatter bomb to the creepers, the alien creatures that share the planet. Mickey had convinced Marshall that he and he alone had the power to tell the creepers not to activate the bomb, when in reality, all he did was bury it in a nearby hole. It would have been a good plan, with none the wiser, except now, winter is coming to Niflheim. Mickey goes back to the site of where he’d hidden the bomb to check on it, only to find it…gone. With the whereabouts of the bomb a mystery, and an entire colony on the brink of extinction, Mickey’s just realized that perhaps burying a weapon of mass destruction in a random icefield wasn’t such a good idea after all, oops! fI you’re looking for a light sci-fi read that’s fast-paced and fun and doesn’t take itself too seriously, this series might just do the trick. (See the full review…)
Infinity Gate by M.R. Carey
Enter the Pandominion, made up of roughly a million worlds—all versions of Earth, just in different dimensions—united through an alliance based on politics and trade. The story begins by informing readers that we will be following the lives of three characters: Hadiz Tambuwal, a brilliant scientist living in her version of Lagos, Nigeria which is a crumbling city plagued by an energy crisis and food shortages; Essien Nkanika, who exists in another version of Lagos, looking for a way to escape his poverty and indentured servitude; and finally, in a Lagos that is highly unlike any of the others, Topaz Tourmaline Fivehills is a sentient rabbit who makes a new friend at school—a relationship that will change the course of history for many worlds across the Pandominion. With Infinity Gate, M.R. Carey has proven he is a versatile writer by exploring what appears to be a new and quite a different direction for him. He hits all the right notes, providing a well-paced, entertaining, and smooth reading experience despite having to tackle some relatively complex ideas and theoretical concepts. (See the full review…)
The Road to Rosswell by Connie Willis
Francie who has flown to New Mexico to be the Maid of Honor at her former college roommate and bestie Serena’s wedding—or rather, she hopes to be talking her friend out of a big mistake. Just like the last time Serena had been about to tie the knot with someone who was all wrong for her, this time her fiancé is a bigtime UFO fanatic and true believer, hence the wedding taking place at Roswell’s UFO Museum on the anniversary of the Roswell Incident which conspiracy theorists believe was a huge government coverup for an alien spaceship crash. A level-headed skeptic, Francie is confident that once she can talk some sense into Serena, her friend will also see how crazy it is and want to call the whole thing off. Upon her arrival though, Francie is suddenly ambushed and held hostage by a tumbleweed-looking tentacled life form—literally abducted by an alien. Thankfully though, it doesn’t seem to want to hurt her. The alien thing, which Francie dubs “Indy” on account of the way it cracks its tentacles like a certain whip-wielding fedora wearing adventurer archaeologist, just wants her to take it…somewhere. What more can I say? There was nothing too cerebral or even complex about this novel, but of course that was never the point. The Road to Roswell succeeded in that it was very effective in being an entertaining and engaging read, and I enjoyed every moment. (See the full review…)
The Ferryman by Justin Cronin
In the middle of the ocean lies the archipelago of Prospera, a utopian state hidden from the horrors of the outside world. Made up of three islands, the largest, Prospera proper, is where the wealthy elite reside, while The Annex is home to working class citizens and support staff. And then there’s The Nursery. As you grow older and your tracked vitals fall to an unacceptably low number, an implanted monitor triggers a “retirement process” in which the citizen will be taken to The Nursery in order to have their memories wiped and their old bodies renewed so that they can restart life as another iteration. Those reborn come back as teenagers, to become adopted as wards by Prospera couples, and then the whole cycle begins again. Our protagonist Proctor Bennett is a Ferryman, and it is his duty to accompany residents by boat to Nursery island when they are ready to be “rebooted”. Then one day, he fails at that task spectacularly with none other than his own aging father, who makes a scene at the pier but still manages to get a strange message out to his son, upending Proctor’s life, making him question everything about himself. Fans of sci-fi and dystopian fiction looking for an imaginative, mysterious, and thrilling book to feed your brain, I promise you will not be disappointed. (See the full review…)
Calamity by Constance Fay
A popcorny delight that launches readers into the Uncharted Hearts series where steamy romance meets spacefaring action,Calmity follows Temperance “Temper” Reed, an exiled member of a wealthy family hoping to make her own way in the galaxy. After refusing to bow to her older brother’s unsavory ways of doing business, Temper joins up with the crew of a ramshackle scouting ship, embracing the newfound camaraderie right up until her intense love affair with the captain blows up spectacularly in her face following his painful betrayal. Living up to her nickname, our protagonist gives in to her impulses and buys the ship from the captain after he puts it up for sale, hoping to keep the rest of the team together. But the purchase ends up cleaning out her bank account, leaving nothing for upgrades…or anything else, really. So when the second son of the Escajeda family hires Temper for a mission to scout out the backwater desert planet of Herschel 2, she literally cannot afford to say no even though she can’t stand the guy. I was surprised to find out that Calamity is Constance Fay’s debut. Not only does it blend genres with ease, but the pacing is also smooth and rapid, delivering plenty of twists to keep readers flipping through the chapters. (See the full review…)
Where Peace is Lost by Valerie Valdes
Kelana Gardavros is a lone sojourner on the swampy planet of Loth where she’s keeping a low profile as just another refugee of the war against the Pale empire. That was five years ago, when she gave up everything in the name of peace, but apparently the war isn’t done with her yet. Deep in the wilderness of Loth lies an abandoned machine known as a demolisher, and now it has come back to life with no way to stop it. But as luck would have it, along comes two off-worlders who claim they can deactivate the machine. Kel, however, is skeptical of their timing. Her suspicion only grows when a friend of hers offers to be a guide for the newcomers, and seeing an opportunity, Kel tags along to keep an eye on things. All these years, she has kept her past life as a knight of the First Sword to herself, but soon she will be forced to make a hard decision. As ever, her instincts are to fight back, but what if revealing her identity also means putting those she cares about in danger? Overall, I had a blast with Where Peace Is Lost, with its snappy pace and endearing characters, lively mix of adventure and action, plus a romance that sneaks up on you. (See the full review…)
The Combat Codes by Alexander Darwin
An interesting mashup of sci-fi and fantasy that also reads like a love letter to martial arts, The Combat Codes by Alexander Darwin whisks readers off to a war-ravaged world where fighting is life and life is a fight—that is, if you are a Grievar Knight. After a war which nearly brought them all to ruin, the nations of the world decided on an armistice. Rather than launching full-scale invasions and weapons of mass destruction, they would select the most elite warriors as their champions to represent them in a system which replaces traditional warfare with single hand-to-hand combat. These are the Grievars, who live by the code to fight so that the rest shall not have to. For Murray, who was a legend amongst the Grievar Knights until a devastating loss knocked him out of commission, his new role as a recruiter meant that he must scout out the most promising young fighters to train in the Lyceum, and he believes he has found his champion in a 13-year-old slave named Cego. If you like action in your SFF, then this is the book for you. The Combat Codes has set us up for some big things, and I’m looking forward to what’s coming next. (See the full review…)
Deadly Memory by David Walton
Deadly Memory is the second novel of David Walton’s thrilling sci-fi and paleontology mashup series, picking up the story directly from the end of the first book, Living Memory. Having recently been ejected from Thailand where her expedition to excavate a mass grave of a new species of miniraptor was abruptly cut short, Samira is back home in Colorado, fuming at the loss of her dig site. Soon, however, she is distracted from her frustrations by a miraculous discovery by her new contacts at the CIA. Meanwhile, the work of Thai paleontologist Kit has caught the attention of Princess Mai Sirindhorn, which is how he suddenly finds himself appointed her new science minister. As the last surviving member of the royal family, the princess is still in the middle of fighting a deadly coup, but she also has a secret weapon up her sleeve. Again, there is the over-the-top nature of the premise which requires major suspension of disbelief, but this sequel was overall exciting and fun, and I am having a blast with this series. (See the full review…)
Defiant by Brandon Sanderson
Defiant is book four of the Skyward series, opening with Spensa dealing with the aftermath of her little sojourn in the Nowhere. While she was gone, though, her fellow squad mates of Skyward Flight have been busy as well, but upon Spensa’s return, the entire team is joyous as they welcome her back into their ranks. Together, they will take the fight to the next level. For one thing, the Superiority has not been idle either, continuing to tighten their stranglehold on the galaxy. With the formidable Winzik at its head, they are launching an unrelenting assault on the Defiant Defense Force, compelling Skyward Flight to meet this challenge head-on. For fans, this novel will be the grand finale we’ve yearned for and is a testament to Brandon Sanderson’s talents. It’s a fitting end that wraps up this chapter for Skyward Flight while leaving readers yearning for more adventure in the next stage in the journey. (See the full review…)
Book Review: After the Forest by Kell Woods
Posted on November 28, 2023 14 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
After the Forest by Kell Woods
Mogsy’s Rating: 3 of 5 stars
Genre: Fantasy
Series: Stand Alone
Publisher: Tor (October 3, 2023)
Length: 375 pages
Author Information: Website
After the Forest by Kell Woods is the latest addition to my extensive list of fairy tale retellings, yet despite its fresh take on a bunch of traditional elements, I may have just hit my saturation point with this genre. Really, it’s not the book, it’s me—in this crowded landscape where stories can start to blend together, this one was a solid entry but didn’t quite leave a lasting impression.
Following a recent trend in “what if” retellings, After the Forest imagines the aftermath of the classic Hansel and Gretel tale by taking a rather cynical view of the two siblings’ lives after they defeat the wicked witch and escape from her gingerbread house. The trauma they’ve endured is evidenced fifteen years later, in the aftermath of a long and arduous war that has left most of the countryside a smoking ruin. Hans is deeply in debt from his out-of-control drinking and gambling, and Greta is working herself to the bone to support them both. Relying on a recipe found in a secret grimoire, she bakes irresistible gingerbread cookies to sell which barely keeps them afloat.
But even then, she and her brother face the threat of losing everything as Greta’s deliciously addictive cookies have made her the target of the superstitious townsfolk and unpleasant whispers speculating about what happened to her all those years ago. As Greta struggles to come to terms with her secret and the powers that seem both a curse and blessing, a dark magic in the forest is stirring. At this point, the story becomes less of a retelling and more of a historical fantasy inspired by multiple fairy tales as the author weaves together several narratives to form a rich tableau of inspiration, pulling from many different sources. Gradually, these threads converge to shape Greta’s destiny, taking her through a series of challenges that will not only shape her personality but also show her the true extent of her potential.
There’s a lot to like here. Woods excels in writing characters you can easily sympathize with, capturing Greta’s predicament in dealing with Hans as well as the prejudices of the town, which can spell death for her if the rumors get out of hand (though the people seem to enjoy her baking well enough). The prose is gorgeous, evocative, and well suited to the type of story being told—a heady concoction of fairy tale and folk magic, historical fiction, and even a generous side helping of sweet romance.
But in this sense, it is also treading familiar ground, echoing the similarly themed works of Naomi Novik (Uprooted and Spinning Silver), Katherine Arden (The Winternight trilogy), Hannah Whitten (For the Wolf), Juliet Marillier (Sevenwaters series), and I could go on. Needless to say, it’s a saturated market, and authors will need a bolder style or narrative to stand out. Don’t get me wrong—for many readers, After the Forest will likely make a splash, though for me, it didn’t quite resonate. Despite—or perhaps because of—the esteemed company it keeps, much of the novel makes me feel like I have been/here done that before.
That said, my reservations notwithstanding, I would still recommend giving After the Forest a chance, especially if the premise intrigues you or if you are a fan of any of the books mentioned above. Honestly, this was an impressive debut, and I would read another book by Kell Woods in a heartbeat as I was blown away by the writing and I see great things in her future. Plus, while my personal experience may have left me somewhat critical of this new wave of fairy-tale inspired fiction, the allure of this genre is absolutely subjective; others might appreciate in this one the enchantment that I found difficult to fully embrace. So definitely don’t let my review dissuade you! There’s a distinct possibility that After the Forest holds the magic you’re seeking within its pages.
![]()
![]()
#SciFiMonth Review: Defiant by Brandon Sanderson
Posted on November 27, 2023 21 Comments
I received a review copy from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my review and all opinions are my own.
Mogsy’s Rating: 4.5 of 5 stars
Genre: Science Fiction, Young Adult
Series: Book 4 of Skyward
Publisher: Delacorte (November 21, 2023)
Length: 480 pages
Author Information: Website
As much as I love Brandon Sanderson, I always get a little nervous about his endings. His skills as an unparalleled storyteller can be a double-edged sword as the weight of expectations for a satisfying conclusion grows exponentially, not to mention I have definitely let my own hype burn me before. Yet, with Defiant, the fourth and final installment of the Skyward series, Sanderson did not let me down. Not only did he smash expectations, he has crafted an ending that feels at once resounding and poignant.
As always with a review of a sequel, please be aware there may be references and possible spoilers for the previous books. Defiant picks up soon after the ending of Cytonic, with Spensa dealing with the aftermath of her little sojourn in the Nowhere. The things she saw there may have changed her forever, but they’ve also provided the answers to a lot of questions she has about her own gifts. While she was gone, though, her fellow squad mates of Skyward Flight have been busy as well, as those who have read the novellas may be aware. But upon Spensa’s return, the entire team is joyous as they welcome her back into their ranks. Together, they will take the fight to the next level.
For one thing, the Superiority has not been idle either, continuing to tighten their stranglehold on the galaxy. With the formidable Winzik at its head, they are launching an unrelenting assault on the Defiant Defense Force, compelling Skyward Flight to meet this challenge head-on. Using the intelligence Spensa has gathered on her journeys, they will have more than a fighting chance. The stakes are higher than ever as the conflict escalates, and the fate of not just humanity hangs in the balance. New alliances have been negotiated and new friendships have been forged along the way, and in the final showdown, every fighter will need to draw upon their unique strengths to stand against the overwhelming threat of the Superiority.
I have to say, the more I turned the pages of Defiant, the more my initial worries dissipated, quickly giving way to hope and then relief and admiration as the plot thundered its way towards an epic climax and conclusion. As a final book, it succeeds in doing what it was designed to do: tie up loose ends, deliver on its promises, and leave readers with satisfying closure.
One of the book’s triumphs lies in the fact that Skyward Flight is whole once again. And indeed, the previous installment, Cytonic, was perhaps the weakest book of the series as well as the strongest argument for keeping the whole gang together. Having Spensa off off galivanting in the Nowhere helped develop what we know about the Delvers, the slugs, and cytonic abilities, but the move also split the focus and disrupted the balance. As Sanderson’s books often feature themes of teamwork, celebrating the victories that result when individuals unite for a common cause, Defiant does a great job hammering this point home.
Certain relationships are also given more attention. Spensa has grown so much as a character, and these changes are addressed in her interactions with her flight mates, none so prominently as her dynamic with Jorgen. Their romance, which has had its ups and downs, gets a jolt of energy in this one, as they reconnect and try to work out some lingering issues. Wait, a couple that actually talks to each other instead of just letting their misunderstandings fester and blow up? Seriously, does this Sanderson guy even know how to do YA? All joking aside though, Spensa and Jorgen are truly wonderful together. While some of their conversations are awkward as hell, they are awkward because they feel real, which in turn makes it cute. Ah, to be free of manufactured drama for the sake of drama, it does feel so refreshing!
I also love me a classic struggle between good and evil. Spensa’s enmity with Brade forms a captivating dichotomy that adds another layer of intensity to the story, and the evolution of their relationship from a mere rivalry is a good example of the superb character development we see in this series. The two are different sides of the same coin—similar in a lot of ways, but in the end it’s the choices and complexities of morality that define us.
In sum, I loved Defiant, which delivered an engaging and impactful conclusion to the Skyward series. For fans, this novel will be the grand finale we’ve yearned for and is a testament to Brandon Sanderson’s talents. It’s a fitting end that wraps up this chapter for Skyward Flight while leaving readers yearning for more adventure in the next stage in the journey, revealed to be Skyward Legacy.
![]()
![]()
More on The BiblioSanctum:
Review of Skyward (Book 1)
Review of Starsight (Book 2)
Review of Cytonic (Book 3)












































